Every middle-class family in Pittsburgh with young children does the same math: can we make the years between preschool and eighth grade work here, or do we cut our losses and move to Shaler, Mt. Lebanon, Cranberry, or a private school? The city offers such families little to tip the balance.

No universal pre-K. No public aftercare. A shrinking school district enrolling around 18,000 students in buildings designed for 40,000, where only 44% of third graders read at grade level and the board rejected its own consolidation plan. State projections show enrollment falling to roughly 12,800 by 2031.

Many families who can leave, do.

Keeping families in the city

Mayor Corey O’Connor should propose the single policy most likely to reverse that: universal pre-K for 3- and 4-year-olds paired with free aftercare for every K-8 student in the city.

Advertise with us

The program should be funded by a dedicated revenue stream, not just corporate tax credits for child care or wishful thinking about nonprofit generosity. And it should be defended for what it is: a middle-class retention policy that retains the tax-paying families whose property taxes fund everything else Pittsburgh already cannot afford.

Lower-income Pittsburgh families already have access to Head Start, PA Pre-K Counts and subsidized child care through Allegheny County’s Early Learning Resource Center. PPS operates 85 preschool classrooms in 39 locations, and scholarships cover most costs for qualifying families. These programs have challenges, but they exist and help people who need it.

However, the family earning $95,000 with two working parents gets nothing. That family will pay $7,500 to $15,000 a year for preschool, then $5,000 to $8,000 for aftercare per child, then probably hit the road. If they don’t leave, such families might be better off reducing discretionary income to fall below these thresholds — which is rational but unproductive gamesmanship that no government should be encouraging.

O’Connor told me in November that the mayor’s office bears more responsibility for children’s daily lives than people realize. “After school, that child’s my responsibility,” he said. “Weekends, holidays, summer vacations.” He is right. He should formalize it into policy.

Paying for schooling

Other cities have figured this out. Denver’s Preschool Program, funded by a 0.15% sales tax permanently reauthorized in 2023, provides tuition credits to all families regardless of income and has served nearly 70,000 children. New York City invested $755 million annually in universal K-8 aftercare, adding 20,000 new seats over three years.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh is certainly not Denver or New York, for good or ill. The question for the rusted-out Steel City is always funding.

I will admit my own tendency to treat the city’s tax-exempt nonprofits as a deus ex machina for every expensive proposal. I have argued in this paper that the free-riding Big Five nonprofits, sitting on a Smaug-sized hoard of $4.3 billion in tax-exempt property, should contribute far more than the $1.07 per capita the city collects in voluntary payments.

I still believe that. But calling on nonprofits and the business community to fund everything from snowplows to preschool runs into the reality that Pittsburgh’s power to compel payments is limited by Pennsylvania law.

Pittsburgh cannot levy its own sales tax the way Denver did — that authority belongs to the county and state in Pennsylvania. Nevertheless, the city controls other levers: parking taxes, the local services tax and the payroll expense tax could generate a dedicated stream without requiring Harrisburg’s blessing.

These would cost Pittsburgh residents very little per transaction, offload some costs onto people whose children aren’t filling the PPS rolls, and generate the millions needed to fund universal pre-K seats and K-8 aftercare.

Advertise with us

Corporate tax credits, the mechanism O’Connor said he wants to explore, could expand capacity through existing child care providers. Perhaps the closed or closing school buildings PPS cannot fill could house pre-K classrooms and aftercare programs, converting liabilities into assets.

Changing the calculation

Middle-class families pay the property taxes that fund essential city services, and when they head for the hills, the tax base contracts and infrastructure deteriorates. Nearly a third of the city’s snowplows broke down during January’s storm because the city already cannot afford fleet maintenance. A shrinking tax base contributed to that. More families leaving will cause worse.

My wife and I, who made a deliberate choice to return to Pittsburgh and raise a family here, currently don’t have to worry about aftercare and like the school our daughter attends. Even so, circumstances change and, absent more middle class-focused programs like these, we do not intend to stay forever.

Universal pre-K and aftercare would alter that calculation for thousands of families like ours. Decline is a choice, and so is the decision to openly offer middle-class families a reason to stay and avert it.

Oliver Bateman, a contributing writer for the Post-Gazette editorial page who writes every other Thursday, is a historian, widely published journalist and author of the Substack, “Oliver Bateman Does the Work.” He lives in Pittsburgh. His previous article was “Pittsburgh businesses can do more for the city when it snows.”