The bad numbers arrived earlier this month like a past-due UPMC bill nobody wants to pay. 44% of Pittsburgh third graders demonstrated reading proficiency on state exams, down from 46% the year before. Chronic absenteeism rose to 34%, reversing modest post-pandemic gains.

The district now enrolls 18,312 students while maintaining capacity for 40,000, an absurd mismatch that leaves tens of thousands of empty seats across buildings that hemorrhage maintenance costs. The school board rejected a consolidation plan two weeks ago, but excuses will eventually run out for educators who keep making them: enrollment projections show the student body shrinking to roughly 12,800 by 2031.

Board president Gene Walker conceded after the vote that the district now finds itself in a worse position than before. He understated the problem. Pittsburgh Public Schools have failed, and admitting this failure represents the first step toward something better.

Drawn to the city

I was born on a farm in Scenery Hill, down in Washington County, where my mother still lives off East Maiden Street in Washington and where relatives remain scattered across Ellsworth and Bentleyville. My uncle still runs a farm in Washington County.

Advertise with us

I live in Pittsburgh now, have for years, and recognize the city for what Kentucky agrarian author Wendell Berry calls a “great centralizing process” that draws resources and people from the surrounding countryside while providing less of value in return. The Pittsburgh I inhabit exists in complicated relation to the southwestern Pennsylvania I came from. Interestingly, both places share the same problem: young people are educated to leave rather than to stay.

My doctoral dissertation at Pitt examined American education financing, and a decade of subsequent research has since convinced me that school funding litigation produces little beyond raised funding floors and endless re-litigation. Courts can declare systems unconstitutional, as Pennsylvania’s Commonwealth Court did in 2023, but they cannot build schools or compel legislatures to fund them. The real question concerns purpose: what are we training students to do, and for whom?

Berry wrote about this in an essay called “The Work of Local Culture,” describing how modern schooling orients children toward faraway careers in hub cities rather than home communities. The schools, he observed, “are no longer oriented to a cultural inheritance that it is their duty to pass on unimpaired, but to the career, which is to say the future, of the child.”

This orientation remains “necessarily theoretical, speculative, and mercenary.” The child trained under such a system learns to leave home and earn money in what Berry called “a provisional future that has nothing to do with place or community.”

The old model collapses

For decades, southwestern Pennsylvania exported its young people to distant cities. The college-bound left for degrees that qualified them for jobs that existed elsewhere. Those who remained often did so through ill luck rather than intelligent design.

Advertise with us

The regional brain drain became a running joke and a quiet tragedy, families losing their children to the District of Columbia and Raleigh and Denver while empty houses and untended cemeteries accumulated on hillsides.

Now the logic of that export model has collapsed. The white-collar economy that absorbed our college graduates faces near-certain contraction through AI automation. Law firms and consulting companies and tech startups require fewer warm bodies, especially young bodies, at keyboards.

For now, Pittsburgh Public Schools continues operating as if the old export model still functions. The district maintains magnet programs designed to funnel high-achieving students toward competitive colleges and professional careers.

That era has ended, much like the Pittsburgh Promise that spurred local students toward higher education will end due to funding shortfalls in 2028. The question before us concerns not what’s next but what’s left.

Berry suggested an answer forty years ago. A good local culture, he wrote, collects “the memories, ways, and skills necessary for the observance, within the bounds of domesticity, of this natural law.”

Advertise with us

A community that cannot preserve and improve its local conditions will decay. The centripetal force holding people in place requires practical usefulness to one another.

What would a Pittsburgh Public Schools system look like if it trained students to remain and contribute?

What the schools could do

Via charter schools and other methods of decentralized learning, the district could teach plumbing, heavy equipment operation, electrical work and HVAC repair, determining in advance who has aptitude for trades that artificial intelligence cannot yet perform remotely and that pay well enough for practitioners willing to show up.

It could prepare students for nursing and social work, fields that will only grow as the region’s already-elderly population ages. It could offer direct, test-mediated pathways into municipal employment: police and prison work, sanitation, parks maintenance. The region still contains some working farms; agricultural education might produce young people interested in food production rather than food service management degrees.

Berry described walking through his Kentucky countryside and seeing “the gullies and scars, healed or healing or fresh, left by careless logging and bad farming.” Pittsburgh’s scars come from different sources: shuttered mills, abandoned storefronts, beautifully ugly houses that change hands from displaced families to childless transplants paying cash above asking price.

Advertise with us

If Pittsburgh Public Schools continue preparing students for an export economy that no longer wants them, the decline will accelerate. We natives must be taught to tend what remains — if only so something does.

Oliver Bateman, a contributing writer for the Post-Gazette editorial page, is a historian and widely published journalist and author of the Substack, Oliver Bateman Does the Work. He lives in Pittsburgh. His previous article was “Corey O’Connor wants to get things done, not bring another ‘renaissance’.”

Wendell Berry’s essay can be read here.