“In the past, it was mere tradition — broken by President Roosevelt and susceptible of being broken again by any president who has captured the popular imagination as an ‘indispensable man’ and has built up a strong political machine,” an editorial in the Pittsburgh Press from Feb. 27, 1951 read in part. (The Press was incorporated into the Post-Gazette in 1992.)
The amendment
The editors were writing about the 22nd Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, ratified 75 years ago. With 48 states in the Union, it took ratification from 36 states to amend the Constitution. On Feb. 27, 1951, Minnesota became the 36th state to ratify the amendment. Two days later, Jess Larson, as head of the General Services Administration, issued a certificate proclaiming the amendment duly ratified and part of the Constitution.
The 22nd Amendment limits the tenure of office for the president of the United States to two four-year terms, with the possibility of an additional two years for the vice president or someone else elevated to the presidency. The amendment exempted the sitting president, Harry S. Truman, who chose not to run again for president in 1952.
The tenure of the presidency had been debated since George Washington’s administration. The debate concerning presidential tenure — and the need for a constitutional amendment — gained momentum during the administration of Truman’s predecessor, Franklin Delano Roosevelt.
In 1940, President Roosevelt broke with tradition when he sought and won a third term. Four years later, FDR ran and was re-elected again, but died 82 days after being inaugurated for the fourth time.
During the 1946 midterm elections, the Republican Party called for a constitutional amendment to limit the presidential term of office. After Republicans won control of the 80th Congress, the House of Representatives and U.S. Senate each passed a version of the amendment. The House accepted the Senate’s revisions in March and the measure was sent to the states for ratification.
Read More
Nineteen states, including Pennsylvania, ratified the amendment in 1947, two in 1948, two in 1949 and one in 1950. Eleven states would ratify the amendment in 1951.
The newspapers’ approval
“The proposal went to the country as a non-partisan issue since President Truman was specifically exempted,” the Press’s editors wrote. “The people have made know their feelings on the in unmistakable terms. In little more than a month 21 states have voted their approval. An obviously essential safeguard against (the) over-long tenure of the presidency is now in the Constitution in obedience to the dictates and good sense of the American public.”
Two days later, a Post-Gazette editorial opined “On the whole, the amendment should benefit the two-party system in this country. Not that we place much stock in the calculated wail that a third term is a certain step to dictatorship, It’s true that with the two-term limit broken twice by Mr. Roosevelt the way was open for a man who captured the public imagination a la F.D.R. to stay in office the rest of his life.”
But, the editors continued, “the danger in that would not necessarily rise so much from the man himself, who after all would be elected by the people, as from the fact that his party could wax too fat in office. It is not good for one party to build up for a vested interest in government — for contented parties, like contented men, grow stale and uninspired. And while the amendment does not mean one party can’t still enjoy Executive control indefinitely, said party at least every 10 years would now have to stand more on a program than on a personality.”
A reader disagreed
A reader and a Press editorial writer had differing views on the newly-ratified amendment in an exchange from March 12, 1951. “We are losing our constitutional rights, one at a time,” wrote Edward L. Evans in a letter to the editor
“I can see no reason to crow over the fact that state legislators have ratified the 22nd Amendment denying anyone the right to be elected president of the United State for more than two terms as president,” he wrote. “It is our constitutional right to elect any person we want regardless to as many times he has served. It is time for that the American people are thinking for themselves and throwing off the yoke placed on them by the thought control agencies — the press and radio.”
The Press editorialist responded: “We’re a little mystified as to how we are losing our constitutional rights by amending the Constitution. Any voter, any congressman or may advocate or oppose a pending amendment or or work for its appeal against his or its wishes.”
They pointed out that the Constitution provides for amendments and a large majority of the states approved it, and also those against it could try to repeal it. “That’s one of many of their constitutional rights. Until a repeal amendment is adopted, however, there is no constitutional right to elect the same man man President more than two times.”
“From the Archives” is written by Stephen Kalinchak, the Post-Gazette’s longtime librarian.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.