John Nance (“Cactus Jack”) Garner, who served as Franklin Roosevelt’s Vice President, famously described the vice presidency as “a warm bucket of spit.”
But the experience of another FDR Vice President, Harry Truman, reminds us that it matters a lot who is picked to run for vice president. President Truman desegregated the armed forces by executive order and dropped atom bombs to end World War II. Great decisions by a great man, but he did both as a President who had yet to be elected to the office.
How have the two major parties fared in their selection of vice presidential candidates?
Beginning with two zeros
Without reference to ideological leanings — or circumstances occurring after the nominations — I’ve developed a 0 to 5 ranking system with 5 having the right stuff to be a great President (whether or not that turned out to be the case) and 0 as a person who was plainly unqualified.
My criteria? Character, emotional stability, intelligence, communication skills, relevant experience, including in the private sector, and success. Deficiencies that should have been unearthed before the nominations count as negatives.
Why now? The Democrats’ choice in 2024 scared me to death. Outside the glare of a presidential election, the parties need to tighten up their vetting procedures.
Let’s start with 1972 because it’s the first presidential election in which I could vote.
1972: Spiro Agnew (R) resigned in disgrace when he pleaded no contest to federal tax evasion charges resulting from his earlier political corruption in Maryland. Thomas Eagleton (D) withdrew as the candidate when his suppressed history of mental illness surfaced. 0 and 0.
1976: Bob Dole (R) fought through a horrendous World War II injury to serve in the House and the Senate and as Chairman of the Republican National Committee. Walter Mondale (D) served constructively in the Senate. 3 and 3.
1980: George H.W. Bush (R) was born into Connecticut society and educated at Yale but eschewed it all in favor of wildcatting in the West Texas oil patch. He served heroically in World War II and briefly in the House, and as our top diplomat in China, head of the Republican National Committee, U.N. ambassador, and CIA Director. Walter Mondale (D) was still the same guy. 5 and 3.
1984: George H.W. Bush (R) was teed up again. Geraldine Ferraro (D) had served a few terms in the House. Her candidacy became a liability when questions arose concerning her earlier financial disclosures in Congress. 5 and 1.
1988: Dan Quayle (R) had served in the House and Senate. Lloyd Bentsen (D) was a decorated World War II veteran, a House member, and a long time senator who chaired the Senate Finance Committee. 2 and 4.
From Quayle and Gore to Vance and Walz
1992: Dan Quayle (R) had another run at the job. Al Gore (D) was born into Tennessee royalty, educated at Harvard, and served in Vietnam as an enlisted man and in both the House and Senate. 2 and 4.
1996: Jack Kemp (R) served in the House and as Secretary of HUD, and was a leading spokesman for conservative economic policies. Al Gore (D) was on the ballot again. 3 and 4.
2000: Dick Cheney (R) served in the House, and as Secretary of Defense, Presidential Chief of Staff and CEO of a major corporation. Joe Lieberman (D) was a career public servant with long and much respected service in the Senate. 5 and 4.
2004: Dick Cheney (R) was teed up again. John Edwards (D) was a successful trial lawyer who served one term in the Senate. 5 and 2.
2008: Sarah Palin (R) was governor of Alaska with a great view from her front porch. Joe Biden (D) was a plagiarist with a penchant for sniffing the hair of young females. As a long time Senator, his signature legislation is credited with destroying many black families. 1 and 1.
2012: Paul Ryan (R) had been a congressional staffer and then served multiple terms in the House. Joe Biden (D) reappeared. 2 and 1.
2016: Mike Pence (R) served in the House and as governor of Indiana. Tim Kaine (D) served briefly in the Senate and as governor of Virginia. 2 and 2.
2020: Mike Pence (R) was on the ballot again. Kamala Harris (D) served briefly in the Senate and before that as Attorney General of California. 2 and 2.
2024: J.D. Vance (R) was a deployed Marine, a lawyer, a venture capitalist, a best-selling author and served briefly in the Senate. Tim Walz (D), against whom credible claims of stolen valor surfaced, served in the House and, as governor of Minnesota, allowed rioters to destroy much of Minneapolis while he presided over a billion dollar public fraud perpetrated by Somali immigrants. 4 and 0.
Six presidential mistakes
In the last fourteen presidential elections, the two major parties have selected credible to highly credible vice presidential candidates rated 3, 4 or 5. Candidates rated 2 were mediocre but not outright objectionable.
Clearly, no candidate with a 0 or a 1 should have been positioned one heartbeat away from the presidency. The fault lies with the parties and the presidential candidates — Nixon, McGovern, Mondale, McCain, Obama, Harris — responsible for their selection.
The need for a more considered approach was never more evident than in 2024. Kamala Harris and the Democrats reportedly passed on the able Pennsylvania Governor, Josh Shapiro. They instead nominated Tim Walz who, if there were a fool’s parade of unfit vice presidential candidates, would perform as drum major.
Peter Kalis was, before his retirement, chairman and global managing partner of K&L Gates, and is now an independent commentator. He writes every other Monday. His previous article was “West Virginia does death well.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.