The recent shooting of two National Guard soldiers has two levels of significance, which are deeply intertwined. First, it is the latest example of the so-called “Green-on-Blue” attacks, a common phenomenon which saw Afghan forces killing their own American allies, though it is the first such attack to take place here.

Second, it is yet another instance of the United States’ heavy involvement in the successive Afghanistan wars “coming home” — a multi-dimensional phenomenon that began on 9/11.

Over four years after the chaotic and ignominious end of the American war in Afghanistan, its shots are still being fired and American soldiers are still falling — though no longer on the gloomy plains of Kandahar or in the dark hills of Nuristan, but now in the shadow of the White House itself.

President Donald Trump’s answer to all this — more troop deployments, railing against immigrants, calling for draconian judicial penalties, saying it was all Biden’s fault, etc., — will do nothing to address what is a deeply rooted historical problem.

Advertise with us

Terrorist but not jihadist

The day before Thanksgiving, Afghan national Rahmanullah Lakanwal opened fire with a revolver on a group of West Virginia National Guards stationed near the executive mansion as part of President Trump’s troop deployments to American cities, killing Spc. Sarah Beckstrom and critically wounding SSgt. Andrew Wolfe.

Though clearly an act of terror, it apparently was not jihadist in nature. Lakanwal was a veteran of a CIA-backed militia who had served the American war effort against the Taliban in Kandahar province and so had been granted asylum here after the militants returned to power.

The Green-on-Blue attacks only began in the middle years of the war, when it became obvious that Washington was not going to change its strategy of heavily arming its purported ally Pakistan — the Taliban’s chief sponsor — and so indefinitely prolonging Afghanistan’s agony. Worn-out and bewildered Afghan soldiers, who had repeatedly pleaded for such a reversal, took out their frustrations on the Americans at hand,

Why did our leaders persist in this self-defeating course of action? Because they were in denial of the fact that 9/11 happened and we were on the ground in Afghanistan again because the United States had allowed Saudi Arabia and Pakistan to dictate which militias the CIA would back against the Soviets in the 1980s.

At that time too Washington brushed aside repeated warnings that there would be terrible consequences for America and the world if these fundamentalist states were allowed to marginalize moderates and place their own extremist proxies in power in Kabul after the Russians withdrew.

Advertise with us

When they were allowed free rein for their ambitions nevertheless and the Taliban turned the country into a safe haven for jihadist terrorists, the Afghan wars came home to America for the first time on 9/11.

America’s continuing denial

The reasons for this enduring denial range from a stubborn clinging to foreign policy orthodoxies to a desperate desire to save face to the influence of powerful special interest groups, though the media does not serve the cause of truth by refusing to place events in their historical context and to trace the chains of causality over decades.

And so in the wake of our defeat there the Afghan wars are coming home again, though in more profound and menacing ways than the last time.

It can be argued that Lakanwal’s attack will not be the last of that particular variant of terror. This added way the Afghan war has come home will carry with it the especial danger of inflaming xenophobia.

Then there is the fact that with the war aim of ensuring that Afghanistan would never again be a safe haven for terrorist having not been achieved, the threat of more 9/11s is back to the level of 2001 — and perhaps even greater.

Advertise with us

The restored Taliban has allowed al Qaeda to open training camps in 12 of the country’s 34 provinces, and its current leader Saif al Adl has called on Muslims from all lands to come to them and receive the training they need to avenge Gaza.

Truth-seeking forums

There are, however, some truth-seeking forums that can lead the way by finally bringing an understanding of its parameters.

The Afghanistan War Commission, a bipartisan legislative commission established by Congress to study the entirety of the war in all its aspects, has been holding public sessions since 2024. Likewise, the civil lawsuit brought by the 9/11 families seeking to hold Saudi Arabia accountable for its role in the attacks holds great promise in helping us understand our historical moment. Both have yet to receive the coverage they need in the press.

Yet the most important way of meeting these dangers will be open and honest national discourse about where they come from and what to do about them, for without it the Afghan wars will keep coming home.

Vanni Cappelli, a freelance journalist, is the president of the Afghanistan Foreign Press Association and a frequent contributor to the Post-Gazette. His previous article was “America’s corrupting alliance with Saudi Arabia.”