President Donald Trump prepares to receive Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman of Saudi Arabia at the White House this week, the prince’s first visit here since he killed dissident journalist Jamal Khashoggi in 2018, while his country is on track to surpass last year’s record of 345 beheadings, many of them justified under the legal concept of ta’zir (“at discretion”).

Yet he will be feted at the White House by the president of the United States. How did we get here?

A veteran war correspondent has put forward a theory. In early October The New York Times Magazine published a special issue entitled “America’s Vigilantes,” in which Pulitzer Prize winning reporter Matthieu Aikins outlined the results of his four-year investigation of alleged war crimes by the Green Berets in Afghanistan.

Aikins argues that the abuses were emblematic of the national response to this particular crisis in our history, which was unleashed by the worst attack on the country since Pearl Harbor.

Advertise with us

The bitter harvest

WWII ended in a decisive victory, with the United States’ emergence as a superpower and the establishment of dominant, rules-based world institutions. In contrast, 9/​11 was followed by “forever wars” that were lost, and only yielded more international chaos and a pervasive disillusionment with the political and military elites who had led us into these disasters.

The bitter harvest, Aikins claims, is the America of Donald Trump and Peter Hegseth.

Worn out to the point of psychological breakdown by the strain of repeated deployments amidst impossible conditions, America’s best soldiers developed “a culture of rule-breaking that led to war crimes and, eventually, a vigilante ethos openly embraced by leaders at home,” he asserts.

“[T]he vision of unbridled power held by the Trump administration had its roots in the lawlessness of the United States wars overseas [and] the seeds of this cultural and political shift were sown” in Afghanistan and Iraq.

Aikins writes of the “dishonesty that had pervaded the war from the start” — though he himself does not say what that dishonesty was. It was in fact a fundamental denial about the origins and nature of the conflict which led to the futile and wasteful prolongation of the war and ultimately defeat, which produced an agonized confusion amongst the American people that was seized upon by a demagogue and his followers.

Advertise with us

Sept. 11 happened because Saudi Arabia and Pakistan leveraged their role as America’s partners in backing the Afghan resistance to the Soviets in the 1980s to pave the way for the imposition of a fundamentalist theocracy. They achieved this by putting the Taliban in power in the late 1990s, and the militants sheltered al-Qaeda as it organized the attacks on our nation.

Americans acted the part

It was critical that Washington come clean about its responsibility for the tragedy.

It needed to break with these frenemies and announce that it was going to fight jihadist terrorism only with allies of conviction, not of convenience. Only in this way could the goal of “Operation Enduring Freedom,” as the war in Afghanistan was called, be won.

Our leaders rejected this necessary cathartic honesty, even going to the length of suppressing evidence that Saudi officials had directly assisted the hijackers. They then engaged in the desperate illogic of resuming military aid to Pakistan — the Taliban’s longtime sponsors — and invading uninvolved Iraq. They set the stage for twenty years of rolling the rock of Sisyphus in the Middle East.

Afghanistan’s army and police were never going to be able to take over the fight and stand on their own, because they were under attack from the well-armed proxies of a much larger and stronger state. The counterinsurgency campaign was never going to win hearts and minds, because Afghans expected to be protected from Pakistan, and Washington was arming it against them.

Advertise with us

America, which had been welcomed as a liberator, came to be seen as just another brutal occupier — and some Green Berets proceeded to act the part.

Isolated, neglected, forced to endlessly repeat a doomed strategy, “many operators had come to believe that the war for which they had sacrificed so much had no clear path for victory,” Aikins writes.

In fact, there was always such a path in plain sight: a tripartite American-Indian-Afghan alliance aimed at containing Pakistan, which I argued for in a 2007 essay in the foreign policy journal Orbis.

Yet this required an honesty about past mistakes and a willingness to sever ties not only with Islamabad, but with its radical Islamist twin Riyadh, which enjoyed the favor of special interest groups such as the oil lobby. This Washington was not even willing to contemplate.

Hegseth’s baseless claims

As a consequence, in a strange twist on the old anti-Vietnam war slogan “bring the war home,” many veterans came to feel that they had been betrayed, and took to self-destructive behavior to express their frustration. Aikins relates how this ranged from substance abuse to drug trafficking to forming outlaw biker gangs, as well as domestic abuse and suicide.

Advertise with us

Yet in the end they and others who sympathized with them settled on looking to a savior who told them that since the elites had never played by the rules neither would he — but would do so in their interest and that of the country, which he claimed he would make “great again.”

This attitude has now been sold to the disillusioned soldiery by the baseless claims of Secretary of Defense Peter Hegseth that the “forever wars” were lost because a jaded elite had neutered the military by making it “woke and weak,” and that he and the president would enable them to be warriors again by throwing out the rulebook.

Yet the cultural shift embodied in Trump and Hegseth’s rhetoric and actions is likewise pervaded by dishonesty: the war in Afghanistan was not lost because D.E.I. policies weakened the military; it was lost because enduring denial can never secure enduring freedom.

And that is something to ponder as this lawless culture born of a necessary but squandered war takes an ax to our most important political, military and civic institutions at a time when jihadism is triumphantly resurgent from the Hindu Kush to the Sahara, with “Avenge Gaza!” as its dangerous battle cry.

Suppression of the truth is always the first step towards lawlessness. Yet it is never too late to recapture the truth-telling and rule of law which made us great in the first place.

Advertise with us

The best place to start is the civil lawsuit brought by the 9/​11 families against Saudi Arabia to hold it accountable for the attacks, which is set to come to trial in New York. There, under due process of law and free from unbridled presidential power, we can discover how we stumbled into this labyrinth, and start unspooling the golden thread that will lead us out.

Vanni Cappelli, a freelance journalist, is the president of the Afghanistan Foreign Press association and a frequent contributor to the Post-Gazette. His previous article was “The Saudis helped create 9/11 and Washington covered for them.”