Legislation called the SAFE Act now being considered in the U.S. House of Representatives would ban federal funding to scientists who have any form of collaboration with China.

That might seem, with the growing competition between our two nations, a reasonable thing to do. Clearly, the U.S. needs to limit collaborations and other activities by US scientists and universities that could advance China’s military advantages. It also needs to be careful not to support or encourage activities that could give China major commercial advantages.

However, a blanket ban on collaboration in fundamental science would be much too broad and could cause great harm to U.S. science. We don’t know how this research will benefit us nor which research will prove to have direct applications, but we know that it will and that the results will be life-changing.

Cold War collaboration

The ban makes no sense. Even during the depths of the Cold War, when America and the Soviet Union had nuclear weapons aimed at each other, American scientists continued to collaborate in fundamental areas of research that gave the Russians no military or “dual use” advantages.

Advertise with us

Joint work took place in fields like earth and environmental science. Through efforts like the International Geophysical Year (IGY) these collaborations resulted in important advances in basic science. They also maintained valuable unofficial “back channels” between our two nations.

While they are unpredictable, and may not arise for decades, the modern world has learned that the pursuit of fundamental science brings many tangible and intangible long-term benefits.

The tangible benefits of fundamental science include modern microchips that enable advanced computing, communications and almost unimaginable amounts of information storage, systems for medical imaging based on atomic physics that now save countless lives, GPS and other forms of precision navigation made possible with atomic clocks, and all kinds of materials with new and useful properties.

Coming decades may bring medical advances that eliminate inherited diseases, incredibly powerful quantum computing, and vast new sources of clean and affordable energy — all built on fundamental understandings that have been built up through decades of basic research.

The intangible benefits include both national prestige, and a growing appreciation of the remarkable wonders of how our universe works and has come to be on scales from the subatomic to billions of galaxies.

Advertise with us

China understands

Today the pursuit of cutting-edge science in fields like particle physics and astrophysics, increasingly involves the use of large and very expensive research instruments.

Western nations continue to collaborate to cover the cost of new large scale experimental facilities, such as optical and radio telescopes and enormous arrays of photodetectors to search for and understand the properties of the elusive almost massless particles called neutrinos — many trillions of which pass through us and the Earth every second.

But these facilities are becoming increasingly expensive and there is no way western nations by themselves can afford to build more than a handful.

China understands the importance of fundamental science and has begun to build some of the largest and most important world class experimental facilities to do fundamental science.

Examples include the world’s largest radio telescope dish, a just commissioned massive new instrument to study neutrinos, satellites to do gamma-ray astronomy, and a range of particle accelerators. In decades to come, Chinese scientists are even proposing to construct an array of satellites to detect gravity waves.

Advertise with us

Who gains

Scientists from other nations are beginning to collaborate with Chinese scientists to design and conduct experiments using these facilities. The U.S. must be careful about sharing advanced instrumentation, but there is virtually no risk from collaborating in the use of such world class experimental facilities and analyzing the data they produce.

Congress could seriously, and perhaps permanently, damage American science if the SAFE Act is implemented without change, and bans all U.S.-China collaboration in even the most benign and fundamental domains of basic research. The only one who would gain from this is China.

M. Granger Morgan is the Hamerschlag University Professor of Engineering at Carnegie Mellon University, where he has long taught and conducted research on climate and other environmental issues. His previous article was “The administration doesn't want to know what the climate's doing.”