Every weekday morning, I leave my Spring Hill home and navigate Penn Avenue's construction gauntlet to get my daughter to Environmental Charter School's elementary campus in Point Breeze, always budgeting for extensive detours around utility work. My commute has stretched from 30 minutes to 45, sometimes an hour, depending on which section of Penn is torn up today.

Native Pittsburghers supposedly won't cross bridges, but my kid's school forces me across the Allegheny daily. The construction ought to make us wonder whether all this pre-NFL Draft rebuilding will prove worth the years of disruption.

Around and around

The $740 million Esplanade development threatens to compound our mobility crisis when ground breaks within weeks. The 164-foot Ferris wheel and mixed-use riverfront project will affect Route 65 (carrying 65,000 vehicles daily), West North Avenue and Beaver Avenue for six years. Downtown's $15 million Market Square renovation reached its halfway point Nov. 8, with construction on the square’s south side eliminating all on-street parking and forcing businesses to survive declining foot traffic.

But for me, nothing matches the seemingly perpetual Penn Avenue chaos in Lawrenceville and Garfield, where ongoing overlapping utility work created what one business owner called "dysfunctional" conditions since March 2024.

Advertise with us

Three separate agencies have torn up Penn simultaneously and without much coordination: Peoples Gas (replacing a 139-year-old cast-iron pipeline from 1886), Pittsburgh Water (removing lead lines) and the city's Department of Mobility and Infrastructure (Phase II reconstruction from Evaline to Graham Street). Business owners report the same patches dug up "three times in a week," with one Peoples Gas crew member admitting "we're not talking to the water company." CBS Pittsburgh warned that incomplete utility work means road restoration may wait until spring 2026 when asphalt plants reopen.

Environmental Charter School families know these disruptions intimately. The middle school students rely on city buses that travel across Penn. Transportation challenges have sparked years of school board discussions and parent advocacy campaigns. The school transitioned from yellow buses to public transit passes for students — 33% of whom qualify as economically disadvantaged — at its intermediate and high school locations. When construction blocks Penn Avenue, those kids face major delays on a primary transit corridor.

Over and under

Unfortunately, Pittsburgh's geography magnifies every seemingly beneficial project's impact. The city hosts 446 bridges, with 30.4% structurally deficient (highest proportion nationally). Only 28 bridges cross the three rivers, turning any closure into massive detours.

The January 2022 Fern Hollow Bridge collapse injured ten people and severed Forbes Avenue for eleven months. The city's 90 distinct neighborhoods, separated by rivers and steep terrain requiring 800 public stairways, foster what State Rep. Aerion Abney described as "the long-standing joke that Pittsburghers live in their own neighborhoods and react negatively to crossing a bridge." Abney rejected this stereotype, noting his North Side constituents had to traverse bridges constantly for food, medical care and necessities: "People cross the bridges all the time."

Historical precedent suggests current pain will last years. Since 2002, Pittsburgh added 110 miles of bike infrastructure, systematically removing driving lanes through "road diets" on East Liberty Boulevard, Forbes Avenue and Negley Avenue. The 2017 "bikelash" saw Mayor Bill Peduto dubbed "Bike Lane Billy," yet infrastructure challenges have persisted from regime to regime. Penn Avenue's Phase I reconstruction (2013-2015), for example, went $2 million over budget, lasted three years with entire blocks fenced off and forced permanent business closures.

Advertise with us

Winter compounds these challenges. Pittsburgh clears 1,200 miles of narrow, steep streets with only 103 of 123 snow vehicles operational and chronic driver shortages. Construction detours plus ice create treacherous conditions on 28 river-crossing bridges. When rain becomes snow during rush hour, pre-treatment becomes impossible and traffic is paralyzed. Asphalt plants closing for winter means torn-up projects remain hazardous for months.

Costs and benefits

The promised benefits remain real, of course: 9,300 construction jobs and 4,500 permanent positions from Esplanade, along with a sorely-needed increase in annual tax revenue from $80,000 to $8 million. Market Square targets NFL Draft readiness by April 2026. Penn Avenue will finally replace 19th-century infrastructure that only slightly postdates the life of composer Stephen Foster, who died in 1864.

Yet execution reveals a city unable to coordinate its own agencies, leaving businesses and residents bearing costs through lost sales, extended commutes and compromised quality of life.

For those of us braving this mess on a regular basis, watching our commutes double or even treble while businesses fail, the question becomes whether Pittsburgh and its incoming mayor can continue to muddle through never-ending transformation and an ongoing “renaissance” so long coming that my late father used to call it a “stillbirth.”

It likely will, as it has endured everything else in its turbulent past, but it won’t be easy. As we natives know all too well, nothing here ever is, including bridge crossings.

Advertise with us

Oliver Bateman, a contributing writer for the Post-Gazette editorial page, is a historian and widely published journalist and author of the Substack, Oliver Bateman Does the Work. He grew up in Washington County and lives in Pittsburgh. His article appears every other Thursday, and his previous one was “Democrats should vote no on judicial retention.”