When FirstBank announced that PNC Financial would acquire the Colorado-based lender, employees past and present learned the price of the institution long known as “The Colorado Bank for You.” For most shareholders, the majority of whom are current and former employees, that price represents the cash value of something much larger and harder to quantify: a culture of ownership that once defined the company.

For decades, FirstBank’s employee stock ownership plan, or ESOP, was a model for how shared equity can transform an organization. Full-time employees who stayed roughly five years became owners, and many stayed for entire careers. That stability helped FirstBank grow into one of the region’s largest and safest institutions, and ensured that those who built the company benefited from its success.

Gain and loss

I reaped that reward myself during my six years at FirstBank, starting as a teller and working my way up to loan review officer. Like most employees, I viewed the ESOP as part of my compensation, a tangible and generous investment in our work. Each share earned felt like proof that our efforts mattered, and we watched with satisfaction as both the value of those shares and the bank itself grew.

Now, as PNC takes over, many of those same rank-and-file employee-shareholders likely feel shortchanged. Yes, they are being paid fairly for their shares, and we should assume that at least some number of employees, who own roughly 15% of the company through the ESOP, voted in favor of the sale.

Advertise with us

Yet with the sale of their shares, so went their voice in the company’s direction, their sense of shared purpose, and their reputation for doing business the right way. These very real but intangible aspects have now been reduced to a number on a statement.

Employee ownership works

That loss is not financial, but social. Some employees will inevitably be “right-sized.” Those who remain will see their workplace and its identity changed. The sense of pride that once came from being “a FirstBanker” will fade, because FirstBank itself will no longer exist. Its reputation as a community-minded, employee-centered bank will shift from is to was, as in, “FirstBank, when it existed, was genuinely concerned about the welfare of its communities, customers and employees.”

To be clear, this is not sour grapes. Only an ungrateful fool could complain about the premium PNC is paying to FirstBank shareholders. The ESOP accomplished exactly what it was intended to: align the interests of employees, management, and shareholders.

In academic terms, ESOPs solve the “principal-agent problem” by turning agents into principals. By that measure, FirstBank’s ESOP was a success story, fostering loyalty, stability and profitability, as ESOPs tend to do.

More than money

But transactions like this one remind us that not all value is reflected on financial statements. When ownership becomes defined by stock price alone, something essential is lost: the mutual accountability and shared identity that make employee-owned firms more resilient in the first place.

Advertise with us

Some reductionist economists may debate whether the acquisition is a net good or bad. Financial statements got a nice bump. Yet on another ledger, the cost to community, to culture, to continuity, is genuine. Those losses don’t show up on quarterly reports, but they matter just the same.

Colin Birkhead is an assistant professor of management at the Atkinson Graduate School of Management at Willamette University. He studies employee ownership and is a former FirstBank employee.