Pioneer cemetery paved over, replaced by Dollar General. It sounds like a parody of the kind of indifference government and corporate elites have for our history, our communities, and our health. But for Steubenville, Ohio, it’s just politics as usual.

It’s the latest unpopular proposal coming from a city government staring at a decades-long deficit of good ideas. And typical of government plans in many similar cities

They dug up the dead

For almost as long as there has been a Steubenville, the plot at 237 South Fourth Street has been public property. Bezaleel Wells, the twenty-four-year-old wool magnate, university administrator and politician who founded Steubenville in 1797, set aside two acres here for a graveyard. For half a century the town’s pioneers, including Wells himself, were buried here.

The city hasn’t let its dead rest since. In 1873 the city decided to erect a school here. The Steubenville Daily Herald commented on the ongoing desecration: “DIGGING UP THE DEAD – Workmen are engaged in digging up the dead in the old graveyards on South Fourth Street. A large number of bodies remain in the valuable sand that have no business there. The sand must be used for building houses for the living and the robbing of the dwellings of the dead must go on even if the bones of our former citizens can find no other resting place than the street.”

Advertise with us

At least we got a school out of it. The resulting institution was attended by local hero Dean Martin.

In 1925, Dean’s old school was demolished and a larger one built in its place. There were so many skeletons that newspapers questioned whether or not graves had actually been removed as required in 1873. Native American artifacts were found too.

In 2004 this school too was demolished, leaving an empty lot. Currently it is used as the city’s farmers’ market. Now Mayor Jerry Barilla would prefer a Dollar General.

“They’ll build a building,” the outgoing mayor told the City Council, in one last effort to broker an exclusive deal using municipal land (the initiative was defeated last year after citizens spoke out against it). “They’ll pave the lot, they’ll put lights up, they’ll pay taxes, they’ll hire workers as part of an economic development.”

Look at Savannah

No one who knows anything about economic development recommends dollar stores. Dollar stores don’t generate business: they shift it around. Steubenville’s citizens won’t consume more Oreos or brooms or Tylenol, they’ll just stop buying them at supermarkets or drug stores, making it harder for those businesses to succeed.

Advertise with us

We don’t really need a dollar store at this location either. Dollar Tree is only two blocks away. Another dollar store is four blocks past that. A new small grocery store, the Steubenville Grocery Box, is only three blocks away, and would face direct competition.

So what can the city do with lots like this? For inspiration we should look to another American city founded in the 18th century: Savannah, Georgia. It is one of the most beautiful, visited, and wealthy small cities in the country. Its secret? Town squares.

Its founder, James Oglethorpe, placed one approximately every four blocks throughout the city. Savannah’s half-square-mile historic downtown today has an astonishing 23 public squares.

This didn’t happen overnight, by the way. When Oglethorpe laid out the first six squares in 1733, the city was just a few log cabins on some flat ground by a river. But it was a good long-term plan, and today Savannah’s citizens and visitors enjoy their uniquely green and lovely historic center.

Postindustrial America left Steubenville with a flat, walkable downtown with lots of historic buildings only an hour away from Pittsburgh. It has two colleges, a hospital, and the county government. But it has almost no downtown parks or playgrounds or trees.

Advertise with us

Town squares turn historic downtowns into desirable, leafy residential neighborhoods. They serve as focal points for public-private partnerships for street maintenance, public art, and civic pride: precisely what our downtown needs.

The city has a chance

Steubenville now has a chance for a bold redesign. Huge portions of the downtown are now empty lots. Some of these — like the one at 237 South Fourth Street — would fit perfectly into a modern Oglethorpe Plan. It’s big, almost an acre.

Its history stretches all the way back to our city’s beginnings. It’s already owned by the city. It’s actually even square.

And it would mean we wouldn’t have to see a Dollar General erected on our ancestors’ graves.

John Byron Kuhner is the owner of Bookmarx Books in downtown Steubenville and writes at johnbyronkuhner.substack.com. His previous article was “Fight Wall Street. Help the little guy. Use cash.”