Pennsylvania still has an anti-blasphemy law on the books that dates back to the 1700s. Ours is one of just six states that has anti-blasphemy laws, alongside Massachusetts, Michigan, Oklahoma, South Carolina and Wyoming.

These outdated statutes originate from America’s colonial era, before the U.S. Constitution, when church and state were entangled and religious orthodoxy was enforced by law.

Still enforced

You might assume statutes like this are forgotten “blue laws” never enforced in modern times. But in Pennsylvania, enforcement happened as recently as 2010.

George Kalman attempted to register a film production company named I Choose Hell Productions. State officials rejected his application because Pennsylvania statute says corporation names are not allowed to be “blasphemous.”

Advertise with us

Thankfully, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania stepped in. The court ruled that the state’s enforcement of its blasphemy statute violated the First Amendment, which protects freedom of speech and religion.

And yet, to this day, the unconstitutional law remains on the statute books. Why? Not because anyone is defending it. Not because it’s needed. But because no one has taken the time to repeal it.

Leaving laws like this in place sends the wrong message. It tells Pennsylvanians that their rights are conditional, that religious speech is protected, but religious dissent can still be punished.

And it leaves open the possibility that someone could misuse the law again, especially since the U.S. Supreme Court has shown a willingness to rewrite constitutional law in favor of religious litigants.

Everyone agrees

Fortunately, other states are taking action to clean up their legal codes. In Massachusetts, legislators are working to address this issue. A bill to repeal an existing anti-blasphemy statute has successfully advanced out of the Senate and is now in the House. If Massachusetts can take this step, there’s no reason Pennsylvania can’t do the same and uphold foundational constitutional principles, as well.

Advertise with us

Even conservative evangelical politicians agree that blasphemy laws are wrong. In 2020, U.S. Sen. James Lankford, R-Okla., introduced a bipartisan Senate resolution calling for the global repeal of blasphemy laws. The resolution condemned foreign governments that jail or persecute individuals for religious speech and nonbelief.

It passed unanimously in the Senate and was also approved in the House by a vote of 386 to 3. That kind of rare, overwhelming support shows that protecting religious expression, including the freedom to question or reject religion, is a shared American value across party lines.

It’s also worth noting that faith-based religious liberty advocates, including the Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty, support repealing blasphemy laws.

They recognize and acknowledge what the Founders believed: True religious freedom requires the freedom to criticize, question, reject religion and speak freely without fear of censorship or punishment.

Religious people benefit from this principle because authentic faith doesn’t need government protection from criticism or debate. When the state steps in to shield religious ideas from scrutiny, it actually undermines the strength and sincerity of religious conviction.

Advertise with us

Repeal the law

For Pennsylvania, the solution is straightforward. Complete the constitutional work the federal court began in 2010. Repealing the state’s blasphemy law would bring its legal code in line with established precedent and reaffirm its commitment to both religious liberty and freedom of expression for all.

Pennsylvania legislators should follow Massachusetts’ lead and introduce legislation to remove the anti-blasphemy statute from the books. By doing so, the Commonwealth can show that it stands firmly with the Founders’ vision: of religious liberty and free expression for all its citizens.

Mickey Dollens is the regional government affairs manager at the Freedom From Religion Foundation.