I don’t get it. Why are so many Republican Members of Congress so eager to leap off a mountaintop into a volcano of public anger, injury and moral disgrace — just to satisfy Donald Trump’s claim that his so-called “Big Beautiful Bill” is good for all Americans?

What is it about this moment that blinds them to the human consequences of their votes?

If the Reconciliation Act becomes law, 16 million Americans will lose their health coverage. According to the Congressional Budget Office, Medicaid alone could be slashed by nearly $900 billion over the next decade — cuts that will fall hardest on older adults, children, people with disabilities, and working families who depend on these services to stay alive and remain at home.

A threat to Pennsylvania

Here in Pennsylvania, Medicaid covers more than 3 million people. In public testimony, Dr. Val Arkoosh, Secretary of the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services, warned that these bills would destabilize health care across the Commonwealth, shutter community providers, and force countless vulnerable residents into poverty. Dr. Arkoosh called the plan “an existential threat to Pennsylvania families.”

Advertise with us

It is telling that Sen. Dave McCormick, in releasing a statement minutes after the Senate version of the bill passed, said nothing about the human cost of the bill. He talked about tax cuts, energy policy, and military spending — but not a single word about the children with disabilities, older adults with dementia, and working parents who will lose their coverage and care if this bill becomes law.

The bill that emerged from the Senate is even worse than the version the House passed. New amendments would force millions of Americans to recertify their poverty or disability every six months — an administrative nightmare and a burden upon many recipients. The George Washington University Milken Institute School of Public Health concluded this will lead directly to mass disenrollment.

Sen. McCormick and every Republican senator knows that will happen. They also know these provisions are not about rooting out fraud. They are about shrinking Medicaid rolls by making it so hard to stay enrolled that people give up.

That is not governing. That is cruelty by design.

Remember Dole and Hatch

Now, the House must decide whether to simply accept the Senate’s amendments and send the bill to the President or to demand changes. If the House and Senate can’t agree on every detail, the bill will go to a conference committee. There, a consensus version will be negotiated — though the only “consensus” Republican leaders seem to care about is consensus among themselves to please Donald Trump.

Advertise with us

It wasn’t always this way. Former Senate Majority Leader Bob Dole of Kansas understood that the best laws happen when Republicans and Democrats work together. He never forgot the people who would be most affected by the bills he passed.

He worked with Senator George McGovern of South Dakota to build nutrition programs for the poor. Sen. Orrin Hatch of Utah crossed the aisle with Sen. Ted Kennedy of Massachusetts to create the Children’s Health Insurance Program. Those Republicans had integrity. They were not afraid to think independently.

Why can’t Sen. McCormick lend his voice to that same spirit of bipartisanship — and that same care for America’s vulnerable?

My brother lives with profound autism, dementia, and echolalia — a condition that severely limits his ability to communicate. He can barely walk. He is not going to be miraculously cured in six months.

Yet under this bill, he and millions like him would be forced to prove again and again that they remain disabled, navigating bureaucratic hurdles just to continue getting help to eat, dress, and survive. How are people like my brother expected to fulfill the bill’s pointless requirements? And who really believes the rules will catch much actual fraud and abuse?

Advertise with us

This is not reform. This does not represent the needs or views of the people of the Commonwealth. This is not leadership. This is a betrayal of the most vulnerable people in our communities.

One last chance

Republicans in both chambers passed this legislation by the narrowest of margins. Now, with the possibility of a conference committee, Sen. McCormick and his peers may have one last chance — one last opportunity to protect millions of seniors, children, and people with disabilities before this bill becomes law.

One last chance to remember that public service is not about scoring political points. It is about whether your neighbors can get the care that keeps them alive.

Sen. McCormick and colleagues: please, think about the real human beings whose lives hang in the balance. If you pass this bill, history will remember. And so will every family who loses the care they depend on.

Gary Blumenthal, a former official in the Clinton and Obama administrations who was until recently vice president of InVision Human Services, headquartered in Cranberry, is senior policy advisor of the National Alliance of Direct Support Professionals. His previous article was “Sen. McCormick, say no to the president and protect the poor.”