The Geneva agreement between China and the United States to slash tariffs was met with collective relief worldwide. Last week’s phone call between Xi and Trump was another welcome development. So is today’s meeting in London between top officials in both the Chinese government and the Trump administration.
As the planet’s two largest economies, both nations bear a responsibility not just to their own citizens, but to the global community to manage their economic relationship with care.
The limits of tariffs
The Trump administration has long framed tariffs as a strategic tool to counterbalance China’s rise across economic, technological, and military spheres. Yet tariffs cannot resurrect a bygone era of U.S. manufacturing dominance.
Labor costs in the U.S. remain high, automation displaces jobs worldwide, and a skilled workforce can’t be rebuilt overnight. This approach has backfired, as the sky-high levies harm American interests more than protect them, inflating costs for American consumers, battering farmers, and stifling job-creating industries reliant on trade with China.
Chinese exporters, too, have felt the pain. But the trade war’s unintended consequences reveal a paradox: While disrupting commerce, it has also spurred China to accelerate economic reforms, and deepen regional partnerships.
Beijing is now dismantling internal trade barriers and tapping into the vast spending power of its 1.4 billion people — including a 500 million-strong middle class buoyed by world-class e-commerce networks. A trade-in program, offering fiscal incentives to replace aging electric products, boosted sales by $137 billion in 2024 alone.
Meanwhile, China’s trade map is shifting. ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) and the European Union have eclipsed the U.S. as its top partners, accounting for 16% and 13% of China’s global trade respectively, while America’s share has dwindled to 11%.
More troubling is the erosion of trust between Washington and Beijing. Once admired in China as a beacon of innovation and openness, the U.S. is increasingly viewed through a lens of rivalry. Even advocates of cooperation on urgent issues like climate change and financial stability now struggle to bridge the divide.
A clash of cultures
How did they get here? A clash of political cultures explains much. Beijing’s overtures — like assisting Washington in curbing the opioid crisis, including cracking down on fentanyl precursors—have often been met with skepticism or outright hostility, such as the 20% fentanyl-related tariffs on all Chinese imports.
Similarly, when Chinese President Xi Jinping met a group of international business leaders in late March — among them some big American names — and said that trade disputes “should be handled through dialogue between equals,” the message seemed lost on its key audience in Washington.
Yet there are signs of pragmatism. In April, China lifted foreign ownership caps on app stores and internet services in pilot zones, signaling openness to global business. After weeks of tit-for-tat escalation, the Sino-U.S. Geneva statement’s recognition of the “importance of their bilateral economic relationship to the global economy” marks a rare moment of alignment.
The question now is whether diplomacy can outmuscle politics. Will China hawks, intent on framing cooperation as weakness, derail progress? Can leaders sidestep domestic pressures? Will promises hold?
History’s lesson
History offers a lesson: Great powers thrive not through dominance but by navigating interdependence. Tariffs may rally political bases, but the real test lies in crafting a relationship where trade benefits both nations—and the world. The true “art of the deal” isn’t about unilateral victories; it’s about recognizing that in today’s interconnected economy, no one wins alone.
The path forward is clear. Pragmatism, not posturing, will determine whether this fragile truce evolves into lasting stability. For the sake of global prosperity, let’s hope wisdom prevails.
Wen Ying is an international affairs commentator who has contributed to the San Francisco Examiner and “China-US Focus.”
Editor’s note: Although not employed by the Chinese government, Wen Ying lives in Beijing and offers a perspective informed by the government’s position.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.