In his address to Congress on March 4, President Trump celebrated investments that businesses from Japan, South Korea and other countries are making in the U.S. and stressed that tariffs would encourage more foreign manufacturers to come here. In a Feb. 21 “America First Investment Policy” memo, Trump directed agencies to reduce barriers to investment from nations that are not identified as foreign adversaries.
So why, at the same time, has the President mimicked his predecessor Joe Biden in disrupting a deal that would bring in billions of foreign capital to help revive America’s third-largest steel company?
Normally a simple decision
In normal times, Nippon Steel’s $14.9 billion purchase of Pittsburgh-based U.S. Steel, proposed back in December 2023, would have been simple. National security isn’t an issue. Japan is a staunch U.S. ally, and Nippon has already shown through its established operations in the U.S. — such as Nippon Steel Pipe in Indiana and Wheeling-Nippon, which produces galvanized steel in West Virginia — that it’s a good corporate citizen.
Besides, if Japan suddenly became an enemy, the U.S. would have no trouble forcing a sale of any plants Nippon acquired.
U.S. Steel, once the largest company of any kind, now ranks 24th on the list of global steelmakers, down from 10th in 2008. Nearly a year ago, the company’s shareholders approved a deal that would have provided the money for the company to modernize. Among the changes: spending $1 billion to upgrade U.S. Steel’s Mon Valley Works and $300 million to revamp the blast furnace in Gary, Ind.
A few weeks before leaving office, however, President Joe Biden blocked the agreement, saying, “It is my solemn responsibility as president to ensure that, now and long into the future, America has a strong domestically owned and operated steel industry.”
Read More
Nippon and U.S. Steel quickly filed suit against the government to overturn the decision, arguing that “President Biden ignored the rule of law” and that, because of political influence, the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) “failed to conduct a good faith, national security-focused regulatory review process.”
Trump sparks confusion
A month later, alongside Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba in the Oval Office, President Trump, who earlier was “totally against the once great and powerful U.S. Steel being bought by a foreign company,” said that Nippon would "invest heavily" in U.S. Steel, “sparking confusion,” as Reuters put it.
The confusion increased when, on Feb. 10, a U.S. investment firm, Ancora Holdings, sent a letter to the U.S. Steel board demanding an end to the Nippon merger agreement and asserting that it was “prepared to lead a multibillion-dollar capital investment program focused on reinvigorating” the company. Ancora offered no information on how ownership would be structured, how the money would be raised or where it would come from.
Ancora is raising a lot of dust for a firm with so little on the line. Admitting that its various funds own less than 0.2% of U.S. Steel stock, Ancora on Feb. 27 proposed a new slate of directors and called for the annual meeting to be postponed. Ancora, which was fined $100,000 in 2018 for a “pay for play” violation by the Securities & Exchange Commission, also launched a skimpy website called “MakeUSSteelGreatAgain.com.”
Meanwhile, Pentwater Capital Management, which holds a 9% stake in U.S. Steel (it’s the third-largest shareholder after Blackrock and Vanguard), is opposing Ancora’s moves and backing the current management.
Nippon is not backing down. The company is continuing to pursue the deal in court and in discussions with the Department of Commerce. Tadashi Imai, Nippon’s president, rejected the notion of injecting funds into U.S. Steel without owning the company. "Only by making an equity investment, we can make a major (capital) spending decision," he said.
On the other hand, Axios last month reported that the Trump Administration “is, at the very least, weighing the possibility of allowing U.S. Steel to go it alone.”
One company needs the other
But going it alone is not what the shareholders and management of this private U.S. company want to do. In accepting Nippon’s offer, they recognized that they need the capital and the expertise of the fourth-largest steel company in the world in order to survive and prosper. In addition, encouraging Nippon and other foreign businesses to spend billions in the U.S. is precisely the aim of the Trump Administration’s “America First” economic strategy.
It would be a shame to allow politics and opportunism to triumph over economic good sense. A merger with Nippon is the best outcome for U.S. Steel’s workers and investors, and for the nation as a whole.
James K. Glassman, a former Under Secretary of State, is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and a member of the SEC’s Investor Advisory Committee.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.