President Joe Biden blocked Nippon Steel’s $14.9 billion acquisition of U.S. Steel, but with Nippon Steel and U.S. Steel suing the Biden administration over its decision, the story is not over.

And President-elect Donald Trump, despite his current opposition, could revive the deal, drawing on his past willingness to reverse positions on foreign business transactions and his recent overtures to Japanese companies to increase their investment in the United States.

The U.S. Steel-Nippon Steel controversy is, moreover, a litmus test for the future of U.S. trade and investment policy.

The problem

The official rationale for blocking the Nippon Steel acquisition — protecting critical supply chains from foreign control — reflects a novel and overly expansive interpretation of national security.

Advertise with us

Historically, the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) never blocked transactions involving allies like Japan, a nation that has long been a cornerstone of U.S. economic and military strategy in the Indo-Pacific. Such deals were generally viewed as supporting national security, since economic interaction with allies enhances bilateral relations more broadly.

That would have been the case had Nippon Steel purchased U.S. Steel — and will be if the deal eventually goes through. The company offered significant assurances, including a $2.7 billion investment to modernize U.S. Steel’s aging infrastructure, a 10-year production capacity guarantee in the United States, and compliance with stringent U.S. oversight mechanisms that would have yielded increased supplies of steel made in America.

The alternative is less realistic and fraught with problems, and therefore our national security. Cleveland-Cliffs, a rival steelmaker that previously bid for U.S. Steel, may attempt to revive its proposal.

However, Cleveland-Cliffs’ financial position, marked by substantial debt, raises questions about its ability to make the necessary investments. Moreover, Cliffs’ acquisition would create a degree of market concentration in steel used in auto production that would almost certainly lead to higher costs for consumers.

And we would lose the benefit of the connection with Nippon Steel.

Advertise with us

Japan is America’s largest source of foreign direct investment, supporting nearly one million U.S. jobs. The Biden decision, however, could lead to reduced Japanese investment and a reevaluation of the U.S.-Japan economic partnership.

Indeed, Japan’s Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba has expressed serious concerns about the decision, warning it could discourage Japanese investment in the United States. Quite justifiably, he asked for an explanation of how a company from an allied nation posed the security risks Biden cited as the critical factor in his decision.

Trump’s opposition

Meanwhile, President-elect Donald Trump has also opposed the deal. But he has also previously changed his stance on foreign companies doing business in the United States. For example, in 2018, Trump reversed his administration’s ban on Chinese telecom giant ZTE’s purchases of American parts for its products and allowed it to resume transactions with U.S. suppliers.

Moreover, Trump has courted Japanese investment in the United States. Just last month, he rolled out the red carpet for SoftBank CEO Masayoshi Son, encouraging him to double the pledge he made to invest $100 billion in the United States, including in sensitive sectors like artificial intelligence, to $200 billion.

Trump’s engagement with Japanese investors and his track record of leveraging foreign investments for political and economic gains suggest he could be persuaded to reconsider the Nippon Steel deal. By framing the acquisition as a strategic partnership rather than a national security threat, Trump could align the deal with his “America First” agenda while preserving U.S.-Japan relations.

Advertise with us

CFIUS, designed to depoliticize foreign investment reviews, has come under scrutiny for its handling of this case. Nippon Steel and U.S. Steel allege that the committee’s review process was “compromised by political interference” and lacked transparency. Economic experts warn that expanding the definition of national security risks undermines global trade norms and deters future foreign investment in the U.S.

The global steel industry is dominated by China, which accounts for nearly 60% of global production. Collaborative efforts with allies like Japan are crucial to countering this dominance. By rejecting Nippon Steel’s bid, the U.S. risks weakening its position in the global steel market and forfeiting opportunities for strategic partnerships, and leaving China in its dominant position.

Nippon Steel and U.S. Steel have filed lawsuits challenging the decision, alleging due process violations and anticompetitive behavior by Cleveland-Cliffs and the United Steelworkers union. These legal battles highlight the high stakes of this controversy.

A litmus test

Trump’s impending presidency presents a unique opportunity to reassess the deal.

By embracing the acquisition, Trump could position himself as a champion of economic growth and strategic alliances, addressing both the economic challenges facing U.S. Steel and the geopolitical imperatives of countering China. With the right framing, Trump could transform the Nippon Steel acquisition from a contentious issue into a hallmark of his administration’s pragmatic approach to foreign investment.

Advertise with us

Again, the decision on the sale provides a litmus test for the future of U.S. trade and investment policy. As Trump prepares to take office, the possibility of reversing the decision offers a path to restore confidence in U.S. investment policy and strengthen the U.S.-Japan partnership.

The outcome of this controversy will shape not only the future of U.S. Steel but also the trajectory of America’s role in the global economy.

Daniel Bob worked on foreign and economic policy, including Asian policy, in the U.S. House and Senate.