I have been thinking about Pope Francis, that good and holy man. Like millions of others, I am pulling for him right now. Has any one person, over the last decade, done as much good?
“I have set before you life and death, blessings and curses,” says Deuteronomy. Choose life or death; decency or tyranny; Francis or Putin and his Mini-mes.
I have also been reading the Pope’s autobiography “Hope.” Interestingly, strangely, it has not been widely, or, for the most part, thoughtfully reviewed. It’s not linear. I don’t think the Holy Father is linear. He’s relational. He’s all about character and the intersections of souls.
A human story of hope
The Christian story, and the Jewish story that is its foundation, is the human story — a story of triumph and fall; devotion and suffering. And of hope, which is not the same as optimism.
Martin Luther King, Jr. said: “I believe that unarmed truth and unconditional love will have the final word in reality.” Christians believe there is a final word. Thus, hope.
But hope is hard work, for truth is usually both demanding and complex. And love even more so.
The pope’s book “Hope” may have confused critics, in part, because, though billed as an autobiography, it is really a memoir, and an off-beat memoir at that. It is very much like the man — deeply human, unguarded, personal, earthy, concrete. The Blessed Mother is not a picture or statue to him. She is quite real: Guiding him and leading him to Christ. And Jesus is his friend and brother. Walking with him.
These are his human categories: Father, mother, sister, brother.
The Christian faith, to Francis, is not one of the “great ideas.” It is a way to live. Faith is not philosophy, though faith and philosophy, like faith and science, are compatible. Faith is a wager and a test: This is either the way to live, or not. I am really trying to live it or not.
So “Hope” is not a theological tract or a series of thought exercises. It is a collection of memories — of family, of life experiences high and low, of humble epiphanies, of sinners who transmute into saints.
Years ago, a priest friend said to me, about a new bishop’s introductory sermon, “It was too theological.” People need a pastor, he said. Or as another priest said about most preachers today — they forget to connect to daily life.
Most of us feel uncomfortable with mystery and poetry. So we resort to abstractions.
Stories and meaning
Jesus tells a story, or one of the Gospel writers tells a story about Jesus, and we want to interpret it; give one simple moral and meaning. But no really good story — the Prodigal Son, George Washington and the cherry tree, Sysyphus — can be improved by a thesis imposed. That meaning will always be reductive.
This is why visual art and music are so important: The art itself will always overwhelm and overrule analysis. And it’s why the art of film is so great: The complex and multitudinous particulars, the enigmatic human variations, cannot be reduced to a theory, a concept, or an idea. The pictures and textures are all. Not to be boiled down.
I’m working on a talk on Isaiah Berlin, the great liberal humanist, who was such an incisive critic of ideas turned to ideologies, yet also the 20th century’s premier historian of ideas. He was a specimen of Enlightenment thinking and the Enlightenment’s most eloquent skeptic.
Berlin was a muddler of truths; a harmonizer of contradictions. For example: Man needs the state. And man needs protection from it. He gave us the hedgehog, who knows one great thing, sometimes maniacally. And the fox, who knows many things, but no one great truth.
Berlin said that Tolstoy was the finest of all chroniclers of the mysteries of the human heart and the richness, variety and complications of human relations. He was a Rembrandt of words. Yet he was the most frustrated and unhappy of systematic thinkers, which is what he wanted to be. Berlin cast him as a fox who longed to be a hedgehog.
Well, all systems fail. “No method. No guru. No teacher,” says Van Morrison. But might we say instead: No ultimate method, guru, or teacher? Even fools can progress.
A lover of humans and the earth
We are uncomfortable with the loneliness of life, what Dorothy Day perhaps meant by “the long loneliness,” so we attach ourselves to tribes. Francis makes clear his disdain for ideologies and tribes. He is a lover of the concrete; of actual, flawed humans; of the earth. Ashes, he reminded us this week, bring us back to reality; back to earth.
It is no accident that the encyclical Pope Francis will be best remembered for is “Laudato Si’” (Praise be to you), subtitled “On care for our common home.” It was addressed not just to the church but to the world.
Francis is a fox who wants to be a fox. And a pastor. He has been pastor to the world.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Help save democracy. Read a book.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.