Almost three-quarters of a century ago, on Feb. 27, 1951, the United States adopted the 22nd Amendment limiting a president to two terms in office. We believe the nation should extend the constitutional limit from the presidency to Congress.
For presidents, but not Congress
Term limits for presidents had been debated but not approved at the original Constitution Convention. George Washington established the tradition that a president served no more than two terms.
In the 1944 campaign, the Republican candidate Thomas Dewey proposed a constitutional amendment to limit presidents to two terms, and the idea became popular. Some states proposed a constitutional amendment limiting the president’s term in office and many candidates running for office advocated presidential term limits.
Responding to the popular movement in March of 1947, Congress approved the 22nd Amendment and the state ratification process began. Pennsylvania was the 15th state to ratify the 22nd Amendment, doing so a month later.
Harry Truman was president when the 22nd Amendment was ratified and was grandfathered in. He believed two terms were enough for any occupant in the White House. He thought that since he had served all but 82 days of Roosevelt’s fourth term plus one full elected term, he had served two terms and opted not to run again in 1952.
Just as importantly, he hoped that Congress would further act on term limits for itself. He was an advocate of congressional term limits for the remainder of his life.
The need for term limits
Why term limits? One piece of evidence for their value is that lobbyists, and the special interests they represent, hate them. They don’t want to see their co-dependent relationships with career politicians come to an end.
Term limits make lobbyists work harder. They ensure a constant influx of new ideas into government. Term limits force lobbyists to make arguments on the merits, rather than rely on sentimental relationships.
As former megalobbyist and convicted felon Jack Abramoff wrote 10 years ago in his new book, “Capitol Punishment,” he opposed term limits when he was a lobbyist, because he believed voters’ choices should not be limited.
But he had another reason to oppose them. “Like almost every lobbyist I knew, I didn’t want to have to build relationships with new members constantly. A representative who stayed in office for decades, and was a friend, was worth his weight in gold.”
He came to believe that “permitting people to rule for decades is a recipe for disaster. Is there really a difference between a permanent Congress and a president for life?”
A second piece of evidence is that term limits make legislators more effective and reduce the power of the bureaucracy. New York University scholar Mona Vakilifathi has shown that term limited legislators are incentivized to enact more detailed legislation and to exert more control over the process in order to ensure that their preferences will be implemented and not left to an agency or a governor to decide.
Career politicians regularly “kick the can down the road,” knowing they’ll remain in office. This has the effect of empowering unelected bureaucrats, since lawmakers are less compelled to control the process and place more trust and power in the hands of seasoned staffers and bureaucrats.
Popular and bipartisan
Congressional term limits are now today’s most popular and bipartisan issue. A Pew Research poll showed 87% of Americans, regardless of political affiliation, support congressional term limits.
With over 151 members who pledged to support congressional term limits now serving in Congress, we are seeing movement to pass congressional term limits.
In the House, House Joint Resolution 12, sponsored by Rep. Ralph Norman of South Carolina, has more than 50 co-sponsors. Once passed by Congress and ratified by the states, it would limit representatives to three terms, or six years, and Senators to two terms, or 12 years.
In the Senate, Texas Republican Ted Cruz has filed Senate Joint Resolution 1, a companion resolution to the House’s resolution 12, which has 15 co-sponsors. But if Congress doesn’t pass term limits, what can be done?
Just as with the debate over presidential terms in the mid-1940s, the states can take the initiative, calling for a convention to adopt a congressional term limits amendment. When enough states request a convention to add a congressional term limits amendment to the Constitution, Congress is bypassed, and the amendment can be proposed by the states for ratification. Or Congress might see how popular the issue is and act as it did with the 22nd Amendment.
A growing roster of states have called for a limited convention to propose a congressional term limits amendment to the Constitution. In Pennsylvania, State Rep. Jared Solomon will be proposing the congressional term limits resolution with bipartisan support.
If term limits are good enough for the president, why not for Congress?
Andy Dinniman and John Eichelberger are Pennsylvania State co-chairs for U.S. Term Limits and former Pennsylvania state senators, the first as a Democrat and the second as a Republican.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.