Once again, our Legislature gathers in Harrisburg for the start of another two-year session. Lawmakers tout the bills they hope to pass – and then vote for rules that give all power to their leadership to decide what measures get hearings or votes.
The end result: hyper-partisanship, gridlock and dysfunction, the product of one of Pennsylvania’s deepest democratic flaws: gerrymandering, a system in which legislators effectively “choose their voters” rather than the other way around.
Gerrymandered Pa.
Gerrymandering fosters political gridlock, prevents compromise, and distances the legislature from the citizens it represents. And Pennsylvania ranks among the most heavily gerrymandered states in the nation, alongside states like North Carolina, Texas, and Wisconsin.
Fair Districts PA, a group for which I volunteer, proposes an independent citizens’ commission to handle redistricting. But despite widespread public support for change — statewide polls show two-thirds of Pennsylvanians favor an independent redistricting commission — our efforts have been repeatedly stymied.
Since its founding in 2016, the group has mobilized thousands of volunteers, collected over 113,000 petition signatures for change and resolutions from 390 local and county governing bodies representing 70% of Pennsylvanians. Nothing has happened.
Changing Pennsylvania’s redistricting process requires a constitutional amendment. That’s an arduous task under the state’s current rules, for four reasons:
Difficulty in amending the Constitution. Any proposed amendment must be approved in two consecutive legislative sessions and approved by voters in a statewide referendum — a multi-year process.
Lack of a citizen initiative. Unlike 26 other states, Pennsylvania lacks provisions for citizens to force legislative action through petition and referendum.
Controlled rules of procedure. At the start of every legislative session, operating rules are adopted. Drafted by majority leadership without input from rank-and-file legislators, they give leaders sweeping control over which bills are considered. Over the past decade, only one of 105 proposed amendments to these rules received consideration.
Ineffectiveness of discharge petitions: A discharge petition theoretically allows legislators to force a vote on a bill stuck in committee. Over the past decade, 45 discharge petitions were blocked by leadership.
Notoriously gerrymandered
Pennsylvania’s gerrymandering is notorious. In the 2010 redistricting cycle, the state’s congressional map included absurdly shaped districts, like the infamous “Goofy Kicking Donald.” The district, held by a Republican, consisted of three parts connected by very thin corridors. The result: the outline of one Disney character kicking another in the posterior.
Lawsuits eventually led to the courts redrawing the maps, resulting in more balanced elections. However, the systemic issues enabling gerrymandering remain.
The 2020 redistricting cycle hinted at what fairer representation could look like. When legislative leaders failed to agree on a fifth member for their commission, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court appointed Mark Nordenberg, a respected academic from the University of Pittsburgh, as chair.
Nordenberg introduced transparency, public input, and clear criteria for evaluating maps, leading to fairer district lines and election outcomes that better reflected the near equal political balance of our state. This was a temporary reprieve, not a systemic fix.
The concentration of power in the hands of leaders compounds the problem. Leaders control campaign contributions, committee assignments, and the fate of bills, making it risky for individual legislators to challenge the status quo.
Adding to the issue is Pennsylvania’s lack of restrictions on gifts to legislators, creating fertile ground for special interest influence. It’s why the state, for years, failed to address pleas for reform of unaccountable charter school funding or to tax oil and gas extraction like many other states, despite overwhelming public support for change.
The dysfunction of Pennsylvania’s legislature is evident. During the most 2023-24 session, nearly 4,000 bills were introduced and only 239 became law — a pattern seen in previous sessions.
Bills with unanimous support in committee often fail to reach a vote in the full chamber. Nearly half of unanimously approved bills in one chamber die in the other.
Whether under single-party or split control, Pennsylvania’s legislature consistently struggles to move beyond its myriad bottlenecks.
Un-gerrymandering the state
Without systemic reforms, Pennsylvania risks returning to the egregious gerrymandering of the past. The next redistricting cycle could undo the progress achieved in 2020, further entrenching partisan gridlock and eroding public trust in government.
Pennsylvania’s challenges mirror a broader trend of entrenched partisanship and legislative dysfunction nationwide. The fight for fair representation, transparent processes and accountable leadership is critical for the health of our democracy.
Change is possible, but it requires sustained public pressure and systemic overhaul. Only then can we ensure that our governments truly serve the people. Only intense citizen pressure will achieve needed change.
Doug Webster of Monroeville is a volunteer for Fair Districts PA and author of the Substack, I Beg to Differ.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.