It is easy for progressives who are rightly concerned about our planet to advocate for populist solutions like suing energy companies in the hope of forcing those industries to pay what environmentalists perceive to be their “fair share” of the climate crisis.
But a pragmatic climate movement must contemplate more innovative solutions. Such lawsuits as those arising in Pennsylvania will burden our citizens financially, from the grocery store counter to the gas pump. They will also further harm Pennsylvania Democrats’ electoral prospects, negatively impacting the very cause they are intending to advance.
Pollution or products
Political activists in Pennsylvania are bringing or considering massive lawsuits against energy companies that supply Keystone State residents the fuel they need to heat their homes and go about their daily commutes. Ideologues in other states are doing the same.
While some Pennsylvania political leaders accuse these companies of polluting our communities, everyday Americans see them as delivering products necessary for their daily lives.
Pennsylvania Democratic Attorney General candidate Eugene DePasquale got it right when he rejected these lawsuits on the campaign trail this year, stating that “simply punishing companies is not going to get us there.”
These companies are not violating any government-mandated carbon emission requirements. They are merely performing the roles Pennsylvania residents are demanding of them.
If these politically motivated lawsuits move forward, the energy companies will have no choice but to pass the costs along to consumers. This will mean higher costs at the gas pump, grocery store, and virtually every other industry in the state that is dependent upon energy.
Demonizing or incentivizing
This is the last thing Pennsylvanians need. Our climate is in danger, but so is our economy. Solutions to climate change must recognize all sides of the problem.
Economic issues were at the top of voters’ minds when they went to their polling stations last month. A full 70% of Pennsylvania voters identified inflation and financial concerns as their top priorities, according to a Franklin & Marshall College poll conducted just before the election.
Many analysts believe that economic pressures led Americans, especially in the swing state of Pennsylvania, to vote for former President Donald Trump. This should be first among many lessons Pennsylvania Democrats must learn from this past election.
In his campaign, DePasquale proposed an innovative response to climate change, instead of suing energy companies. He proposed that rather than demonizing the fossil fuel industry, businesses be given positive economic incentives to prioritize energy efficiency and the creation of green jobs.
Tax credits and tax cuts for companies and homes that operate more efficiently are a great first step to addressing these issues without ignoring the economic hardships of Pennsylvanians.
Other policies could focus on funding public transit in high-traffic areas to give commuters more viable travel options. In addition, investing in new technologies that provide alternative sources of energy production would have the added benefit of creating more jobs.
Policies or lawsuits
The solution to climate change is found in innovative policies, not partisan lawsuits. These legal battles will drag on as consumers foot the bill for the growing costs of litigation. Meanwhile, prices continue to rise and advocates will have done nothing to promote a more stable environmental outlook.
Offering tangible economic relief to everyday consumers is a path back to relevance for Democrats, increasing their chances to win elections again and save our planet. Failing to recognize this point — and refusing to respond to the mandate for economic relief that voters provided this November — will do neither.
Jason Altmire, who served three terms in the U.S. House of Representatives from Pennsylvania’s 4th Congressional District, is the author of “Dead Center: How Political Polarization Divided America and What We Can Do About It.” His previous article was “Mr. Biden, if you want to continue as president, take a lesson from Mr. Fetterman.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.