In 2024 citizens of the United States elected knowingly a rapist for president. In 1800 citizens of the United States chose a rapist for president, though he would not be exposed till two years later, and the exposure wouldn’t affect his reputation for almost 200 years.

It appears that one’s station in life, not one’s deportment, most defines — and has defined — the lot in life of Americans throughout our nation’s checkered history.

Trump and Carroll

Rich and famous caucasian New York City real estate developer and television actor Donald Trump sexually assaulted E. Jean Carroll in a dressing room in Manhattan’s Bergdorf Goodman specialty store in the late 1990s.

Advertise with us

Through a special feature of New York State law, Ms. Carroll won a civil lawsuit against the 45th president in 2023. Her case was buttressed by evidence that her attacker had victimized others. The trial before Judge Lewis A. Kaplan concluded that Trump’s assault on the former Elle magazine columnist was, in everyday parlance, rape.

Because of the widespread coverage of the scandal, the world knew of the verdict against the real estate tycoon and his status as adjudged rapist. He is America’s choice, nonetheless, for 47th president of the United States.

Jefferson and Hemings

When patrician Martha Wayles Skelton married Virginia aristocrat Thomas Jefferson in 1772, the slave Sarah “Sally” Hemings was not yet born. But, as a slave girl in the Jefferson household, nine-year-old Sally Hemings was present, it is reported, at Martha’s deathbed when she exacted a promise from Thomas Jefferson never to remarry. Taking the slave girl Sally Hemings as his concubine, he did not need to remarry.

Much is known about Thomas Jefferson as Founding Father, President of the United States and the flowery author of “all men are created equal.”

Advertise with us

Less is known about Thomas Jefferson as enslaver, pedophile and rapist victimizer of the young and enslaved Sally Hemings.

Jefferson defenders have described the Jefferson/Hemings intimacy as consensual or outright non-existent. Jefferson never responded to the accusations and his family denied it.

Some claim that she agreed to be Jefferson’s mistress when at a 16 year old girl when she was in France, as his daughter’s slave. Slavery was not permitted on French soil after the French Revolution (though it continued to flourish in francophone colonies).

Poor country-girl Sally would have to have made her way to French authorities to petition for freedom and not just from any American, but from the American minister to France. Lack of French fluency along with that reality render ludicrous the notion of Sally Hemings ‘’letting’’ Thomas Jefferson (in Donald Trump’s nomenclature) do what he did.

Monticello.org, however, caretaker of the Jefferson homestead, recognizes Thomas Jefferson as the father of six children by Sally Hemings, four of whom — Beverly, Harriet, Madison and Eston — lived into adulthood.

Advertise with us

That is consistent with 1998 DNA analysis. Further, in 2017, an area described as Sally Hemings’ room by Monticello archeologists was discovered next to Thomas Jefferson’s bedroom.

As Monticello.org explains, “Enslaved women had no legal right to consent. Their masters owned their labor, their bodies, and their children.”

Those who consider pedophile too caustic a reference should note that Sally Hemings was a child of 16 when she carried her first Jefferson baby. Thomas Jefferson was middle-aged.

How the stories end

Today, we know not how the Donald Trump rape story will end. Although he still owes E. Jean Carroll nearly $100 million for raping her and defaming her more than once, his reelection perhaps revived his previously sinking stock wealth.

As for the rapist third U.S. president, a spendthrift, he died more than $107,000 — the equivalent of $3 million today — in debt on the Fourth of July in 1826.

Advertise with us

Before that, news of Mr. Jefferson carrying on with the slave girl first appeared in the Richmond Record in articles by James Callender in September 1802. “It is well known,” he wrote, “that the man, whom it delighteth the people to honor, keeps, and for many years has kept, as his concubine, one of his own slaves. Her name is SALLY.” The journalist was found drowned in the James River in July 1803.

Robert Hill, former vice chancellor for public affairs at the University of Pittsburgh, is an award-winning Pittsburgh writer and communications consultant, and a regular contributor to the Post-Gazette. His previous article was “An organization that always sought justice.”