Pennsylvanians have suffered the most significant price increases in the Mid-Atlantic region. Grocery prices were up 8% last year, and home prices skyrocketed by 6%.
Pennsylvania’s renters have not been spared. No wonder housing is a top concern for Pennsylvanians as the election approaches.
With just days to go before presidential election day, Vice President Kamala Harris is arguing that more government is the solution, tweeting on Oct. 21 that she will “go after corporate price gouging.”
More specifically, she has proposed rent control, both capping rent price increases and clamping down on landlords’ use of algorithmic pricing software.
But rent control makes housing more expensive.
More expensive housing
A 2019 Stanford study found that “rent control limits renters’ mobility by 20 percent,” all while “‘landlords treated by rent control reduce rental housing supplies by 15 percent,” likely driving prices up over time.
That is why, today, rent control exists almost exclusively in the New York metropolitan area, home to the most expensive real estate in America. Most of the country has already learned its lesson from this failed policy experiment.
Rather than helping Pennsylvanians find more and better housing, Harris’ rent cap and pricing technology ban would further limit their housing options and make renters pay even more.
Rent prices haven’t gotten higher out of nowhere. From mortgage payments to property taxes to repairs and upkeep, there are costs associated with putting a property up on the market.
Since 2019, these costs have gotten significantly higher due to inflation. Harris’ rent cap ignores these realities under the faulty assumption that landlords have raised their prices out of greed.
While the government can ignore these inflationary realities, entrepreneurs cannot. With a rent cap making it more difficult for them to make a profit, they build less and maintain and improve existing rental units less.
Over time, this drives down the availability and quality of housing. That’s bad news for renters as less and poorer housing supply means higher demand for the units that remain available, which paradoxically pushes up rents even for poorly maintained units.
Banning landlords’ pricing software would be just as counterproductive as a rent price cap and for all the same reasons.
Interest and inflation
This inflationary economic environment has already made it difficult for landlords to make a profit.
Banning tools like landlords’ software, which helps them better understand what the market is bearing, will just lead to less property managers serving the marketplace. That will lead to fewer units being available to prospective tenants and higher prices for those that remain available.
As Heritage Foundation economist Steve Moore put it, “Ironically, the government already uses software algorithms all the time — to help price its toll-road charges, for example, or to set prices on Amtrak trains when passenger demand is high. Why is it a crime when private businesses do the same?”
A serious housing solution would be to get inflation and interest rates under control while decreasing the market regulations that have made both building and purchasing housing difficult, but voters will likely never hear a peep from Harris about either point.
Interest rates are currently making everything expensive, but thus far, the Biden-Harris administration has not been willing to address this matter.
The same goes for inflation. With Keystone State construction costs increasing by 13.7%, Pennsylvania’s landlords aren’t increasing prices because of greed or price-fixing. They are raising prices because it costs them far more to develop and maintain their properties.
The Biden-Harris administration reducing its tax and spend policies would help reverse this concerning trend, but it has continued unabated with its inflationary agenda.
Studies show that regulations increase home prices and limit market supply. It’s easy to understand why.
Mandating the use of expensive green energy sources is making the permitting process more lengthy and costly than ever before. Prohibiting straightforward items like prefabricated materials all boost costs on builders, landlords, and tenants. Eliminating or reforming these restrictions would do wonders for the market.
Competition and innovation
Competition, development, and market incentives work. Technological innovation also helps. Harris’ approach to housing doesn’t. It threatens to undermine these proven solutions by curbing development and stifling innovation. Rather than allowing the market to adjust and grow, she is doubling down on heavy-handed policies that have repeatedly failed.
If the federal government continues down the current path of regulation and government control, it will only push affordable housing further out of reach.
It’s time to let the market, not the government, drive the housing marketplace. We’ll all be better off.
Rick Santorum represented Pennsylvania in the Senate from 1995 to 2007.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.