Penn­syl­va­nians have suf­fered the most sig­nifi­cant price in­creases in the Mid-At­lan­tic re­gion. Gro­cery prices were up 8% last year, and home prices sky­rock­eted by 6%.

Penn­syl­va­nia’s rent­ers have not been spared. No won­der hous­ing is a top con­cern for Penn­syl­va­nians as the elec­tion ap­proaches.

With just days to go be­fore pres­i­den­tial elec­tion day, Vice Pres­i­dent Kamala Har­ris is ar­gu­ing that more gov­ern­ment is the solu­tion, tweet­ing on Oc­t. 21 that she will “go af­ter cor­po­rate price goug­ing.”

More spe­cif­i­cally, she has pro­posed rent con­trol, both cap­ping rent price in­creases and clamp­ing down on land­lords’ use of al­go­rith­mic pric­ing soft­ware.

Advertise with us

But rent con­trol makes hous­ing more ex­pen­sive.

More ex­pen­sive hous­ing

A 2019 Stan­ford study found that “rent con­trol lim­its rent­ers’ mo­bil­ity by 20 per­cent,” all while “‘land­lords treated by rent con­trol re­duce rental hous­ing sup­plies by 15 per­cent,” likely driv­ing prices up over time.

That is why, to­day, rent con­trol ex­ists al­most ex­clu­sively in the New York met­ro­pol­i­tan area, home to the most ex­pen­sive real es­tate in Amer­ica. Most of the coun­try has al­ready learned its les­son from this failed pol­icy ex­per­i­ment.

Rather than help­ing Penn­syl­va­nians find more and bet­ter hous­ing, Har­ris’ rent cap and pric­ing tech­nol­ogy ban would fur­ther limit their hous­ing op­tions and make rent­ers pay even more.

Rent prices ha­ven’t got­ten higher out of no­where. From mort­gage pay­ments to prop­erty taxes to re­pairs and up­keep, there are costs as­so­ci­ated with put­ting a prop­erty up on the mar­ket.

Advertise with us

Since 2019, these costs have got­ten sig­nifi­cantly higher due to in­fla­tion. Har­ris’ rent cap ig­nores these re­al­i­ties un­der the faulty as­sump­tion that land­lords have raised their prices out of greed.

While the gov­ern­ment can ig­nore these in­fla­tion­ary re­al­i­ties, en­tre­pre­neurs can­not. With a rent cap mak­ing it more dif­fi­cult for them to make a profit, they build less and main­tain and im­prove ex­ist­ing rental units less.

Over time, this drives down the avail­abil­ity and qual­ity of hous­ing. That’s bad news for rent­ers as less and poorer hous­ing sup­ply means higher de­mand for the units that re­main avail­able, which par­a­dox­i­cally pushes up rents even for poorly main­tained units.

Ban­ning land­lords’ pric­ing soft­ware would be just as coun­ter­pro­duc­tive as a rent price cap and for all the same rea­sons.

In­ter­est and in­fla­tion

This in­fla­tion­ary eco­nomic en­vi­ron­ment has al­ready made it dif­fi­cult for land­lords to make a profit.

Advertise with us

Ban­ning tools like land­lords’ soft­ware, which helps them bet­ter un­der­stand what the mar­ket is bear­ing, will just lead to less prop­erty man­ag­ers serv­ing the mar­ket­place. That will lead to fewer units be­ing avail­able to pro­spec­tive ten­ants and higher prices for those that re­main avail­able.

As Her­i­tage Foun­da­tion econ­o­mist Steve Moore put it, “Iron­i­cally, the gov­ern­ment al­ready uses soft­ware al­go­rithms all the time — to help price its toll-road charges, for ex­am­ple, or to set prices on Am­trak trains when pas­sen­ger de­mand is high. Why is it a crime when pri­vate busi­nesses do the same?”

A se­ri­ous hous­ing solu­tion would be to get in­fla­tion and in­ter­est rates un­der con­trol while de­creas­ing the mar­ket reg­u­la­tions that have made both build­ing and pur­chas­ing hous­ing dif­fi­cult, but vot­ers will likely never hear a peep from Har­ris about ei­ther point.

In­ter­est rates are cur­rently mak­ing ev­ery­thing ex­pen­sive, but thus far, the Biden-Har­ris ad­min­is­tra­tion has not been will­ing to ad­dress this mat­ter.

The same goes for in­fla­tion. With Key­stone State con­struc­tion costs in­creas­ing by 13.7%, Penn­syl­va­nia’s land­lords aren’t in­creas­ing prices be­cause of greed or price-fix­ing. They are rais­ing prices be­cause it costs them far more to de­velop and main­tain their prop­er­ties.

Advertise with us

The Biden-Har­ris ad­min­is­tra­tion re­duc­ing its tax and spend pol­i­cies would help re­verse this con­cern­ing trend, but it has con­tin­ued un­abated with its in­fla­tion­ary agenda.

Studies show that reg­u­la­tions in­crease home prices and limit mar­ket sup­ply. It’s easy to un­der­stand why.

Man­dat­ing the use of ex­pen­sive green en­ergy sources is mak­ing the per­mit­ting pro­cess more lengthy and costly than ever be­fore. Pro­hib­it­ing straight­for­ward items like pre­fab­ri­cated ma­teri­als all boost costs on build­ers, land­lords, and ten­ants. Elim­i­nat­ing or re­form­ing these re­stric­tions would do won­ders for the mar­ket.

Com­pe­ti­tion and in­no­va­tion

Com­pe­ti­tion, de­vel­op­ment, and mar­ket in­cen­tives work. Tech­no­log­i­cal in­no­va­tion also helps. Har­ris’ ap­proach to hous­ing doesn’t. It threat­ens to un­der­mine these proven solu­tions by curb­ing de­vel­op­ment and sti­fling in­no­va­tion. Rather than al­low­ing the mar­ket to ad­just and grow, she is dou­bling down on heavy-handed pol­i­cies that have re­peat­edly failed.

If the fed­eral gov­ern­ment con­tin­ues down the cur­rent path of reg­u­la­tion and gov­ern­ment con­trol, it will only push af­ford­able hous­ing fur­ther out of reach.

Advertise with us

It’s time to let the mar­ket, not the gov­ern­ment, drive the hous­ing mar­ket­place. We’ll all be bet­ter off.

Rick San­to­rum rep­re­sented Penn­syl­va­nia in the Senate from 1995 to 2007.