Beyond rising threats to election officials and fears of lone-wolf attacks, many are asking whether the presidential election will lead to instances of mass, collective political violence — where large crowds assemble at the behest of a political leader and seek to alter initial election results in favor of that leader.
We tried to find an answer to this question from people at the rally Donald Trump held in Butler on Oct. 5 and the people at the rally Kamala Harris held in Erie on Oct. 14. The findings were unsettling.
Risk of violence
Although there are no crystal balls, the best window into this question are political rallies, particularly the attitudes of the rally goers. Our findings, while perhaps not unexpected, suggest there is a real risk of post-election collective violence, particularly if Trump loses the election.
Pennsylvania is a key battleground state in the upcoming presidential election. Western Pennsylvania, in particular, has been a recent focus of both campaigns.
We arrived early in the morning of each rally and asked attendees to fill out surveys, which they could do while waiting in line. Eighty-one Trump and 190 Harris rally goers answered our questions.
Admittedly these are small samples that may not be representative of the average rally goer. After all, these are the subset of rally goers who felt comfortable enough to take a survey by two University of Chicago academics and might therefore be expected to be among the more moderate attendees. If true, that is even more reason the results should give us pause.
Read More
The results show that both sets of rally goers are highly enthusiastic about their preferred candidates (as expected) and that they are also (more unsettling) angry, feel in personal danger from the other party, and indicate high levels of willingness to attend violent protests if their candidate loses. The results are also especially concerning about the risks of collective violence should Trump lose.
Trump supporters believe Trump will win the election and simultaneously express concern in a fair election. Our results found that the majority (62%) of Trump rally-goers we surveyed are highly confident that Trump will win the election, while only 39% of Harris rally-goers are confident that Harris will win.
Angry and possibly violent
However, most Trump rally-goers express low confidence that the election will be accurately counted (56% do not believe the election will be accurately counted and another 19% unsure).
On the other hand, 91% of Harris rally-goers are confident that the election will be accurately counted. Trump rally-goers also maintain the belief that the last election was stolen and that Biden is an illegitimate president (81%).
These findings are concerning, suggesting that Trump’s most ardent supporters will not accept the results of the election should Trump lose.
Rally-goers are angry and blame the opposing party. In addition, the vast majority of rally-goers we surveyed reported that the opposing party makes them feel angry (77% of those supporting Trump; 90% of those supporting Harris), and personally unsafe (77% of those supporting Trump; 86% of those supporting Harris).
Coupled with those feelings, 71% of Trump rally-goers vs. 46% of Harris rally-goers believe that the other party is mainly to blame for why people like them can’t get ahead. In addition, nearly half (48%) of Trump rally-goers (vs. 2% of Harris rally-goers) believe that the people who stormed the capital on Jan. 6 are patriots.
Importantly, both Trump and Harris rally-goers support violence; 19% of Trump rally-goers believe that the use of force is justified to restore Trump to presidency as compared to 14% of Harris rally-goers who believe the use of force is justified to prevent Trump from being president.
In addition, 36% of Trump rally-goers would attend a protest against an election unfair to their candidate, even if it would turn violent, as would 25% of Harris rally-goers.
These survey respondents went to rallies to support their candidate before the election, and the views they espouse suggest that they will mobilize to support their candidates after the election as well.
The inciting candidate
However, there is one more fact to consider. As important are the rally goers’ feelings of anger, concerns over personal safety, and blame, there is only one candidate who has demonstrated the willingness to call together an angry crowd of supporters and incite them to engage in an act of collective political violence: Donald Trump, on Jan. 6.
Our findings give us a window, however imperfect, into the potential that Trump could, at his whim, assemble an angry crowd a la Jan. 6 at any number of places critical to the outcome of the election.
If Pennsylvania is predictive of the nation, we should all be concerned about violence should Trump lose the election.
Robert A. Pape is professor of political science and director of the University of Chicago Project on Security and Threats. Miranda P. Kaye is the director of the University of Chicago Survey Lab.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.