Thoughtful pro-life voters are questioning how this presidential election will affect the lives of women and their unborn children. Would electing Kamala Harris increase the abortion rate? Would Donald Trump sign a federal abortion ban?

As a family physician who cares for pregnant women and their children, I’ve met many women facing unintended pregnancies. Many weep but ultimately decide to continue their pregnancies.

Others say, “I can’t afford to have a child … It’s not the right time ... I’m too old ... I’m in school ... I need to work to provide for my family ... I’m worried about my other children.”

Women’s reasons

Advertise with us

While reasons women seek abortion are complex and interrelated, the findings of large studies reflect my experience.

Many women cite financial reasons, fear of not being able to provide, inadequate housing or lack of employment. Others say it’s bad timing, feel it’s unfair to their other children, or are worried that having a baby would interfere with their education or careers.

Because women have compelling reasons why they seek abortion, bans in countries around the world have not decreased rates. And among high-income countries, abortion rates are actually higher where abortion is prohibited than where is it broadly legal. Following the Supreme Court’s reversal of Roe v. Wade, the U.S. has seen an increase in the abortion rate.

Since restricting access to abortion does not decrease the rate, pro-life advocates who want to preserve human life from conception need to consider more practical solutions. Addressing the reasons why women frequently seek abortion would be a more effective way to support women carrying unintended pregnancies.

Harris v. Trump

Advertise with us

The Harris/Walz campaign’s “A New Way Forward for the Middle Class” outlines policies to create economic opportunity for working Americans, “lower costs for families ... cut taxes for working people ... [and] lower food and grocery costs.”

Harris will increase the tax credit for families with children, including a $6,000 tax credit for families with newborns, to help cover costs of diapers, clothes, car seats and other necessities. Additionally, she has specific strategies to increase wages for workers and improve job opportunities, all while ensuring families making less than $400,000 per year won’t face tax increases.

Contrast these policies with Trump’s plans to give billionaires tax-cuts and raise tariffs on imported groceries, clothing and other essentials, leading to higher costs for families with children.

Harris is committed to ensuring high-quality, low-cost childcare, which will reduce barriers for women with young children who are working or in school. In 2023, the average cost of childcare was $11,582, a number out of reach for many families.

She has pledged that childcare will not cost families more than 7% of their annual income. In contrast, the Project 2025 agenda would cut funding for childcare and eliminate Head Start, which makes up to 22% of the overall childcare supply in rural areas.

Advertise with us

Harris has proposed a comprehensive plan to expand affordable housing, incentivizing the construction of rental housing and homes for first-time buyers. She has also consistently fought to lower health care costs and will continue to make health care access a priority.

Trump’s administration tried unsuccessfully to repeal the Affordable Care Act in his first term. Harris understands that affordable healthcare is a cornerstone of building healthy families.

New pro-life questions

As we approach the polls, thoughtful pro-life voters may want to begin asking new questions:

What if women in school or working to provide for their families knew they would have access to high-quality low-cost childcare? What if more women facing unintended pregnancies could see a way forward and continue carrying a child with a more secure financial future?

Advertise with us

What if abortion were broadly legal but rarely needed?

Would electing Harris help save the lives of more women and their unborn children?

Susan Kraus is a family physician in central California who cares for patients in all stages of life.