As a lawyer, hearing after hearing, I watch litigators buy their way out of a jam with statements that are technically true but in reality are the furthest thing from it. As I’m watching another lawyer make her case to the people of Pennsylvania, I can tell you, “I know her type” and while I’m sure her promise to not ban fracking would be technically true, it’s going to leave the cornerstone of the keystone state strangely and sadly different.
As a child of Appalachia, I’ve seen this before.
Shutting down coal
I’m blessed to be a prosecutor in Hazard, Kentucky, the place I’ve lived and worked all my life. For generations Hazard was the heart of coal country.
Seemingly perpetually, our coal production per capita outpaced any county in the state and most counties in the coal basin, and was the driving force in our economy, giving a small mountain town more millionaires per capita than any place on earth. It was a way of life that kept pockets full, the lights on, and enabled Kentucky to position itself for some of it’s biggest economic wins on record, luring the likes of Toyota to the Bluegrass state with promises of the lowest utility rates in the country.
Then came 2008. While we all thought the financial crisis was the worst of our worries at the time, we’d soon find that that wouldn’t be the half of it for us. President Barack Obama came to office with an ambitious agenda that an eager nation seemed to yearn for, including an economy focused on the middle class and cleaner dependable energy (sound familiar?).
The energy plan seemed straightforward and agreeable. Limit pollutants into major waterways that served Appalachia.
Read More
But that simple approach led to a much more ambitious agenda. While Obama’s administration didn’t ban mountaintop removal coal mining (the most efficient method of extraction), he proved that he didn’t have to ban it to end it.
Starting with more stringent permit reviews that ensured stringent compliance with the clean water regulations, moving to “limitations” on further mining on public lands, and finally adding the stream protection rule that limited mining activity to areas more than 100 feet from a stream, little by little, the administration found ways to effectively ensure that any future energy producer focused on coal would be bankrupted.
Who suffered
One by one, operations that had yielded millions of tons closed. People who had shown up day in and day out to the only job they’d ever known had no place to work. As one operator after another was forced to look their men in the eye and admit that they couldn’t make it work, one family after the next was forced to leave home behind.
It wouldn’t stop there. For those of us left, our utility rates would skyrocket. Tighter regulations on CO2 emissions from coal fired plants promised by the administration led blue chip American Electric Power to decommission its plants and invest over a billion dollars to install scrubbers and convert coal plants to other energy sources.
Those costs, increasing year over year, were passed directly to the rate payers in some of the most struggling areas of the country. I know any number of families living in single wide mobile homes who see $600 utility bills every month the heat is on.
I wrote this as a warning, as somber as the ghost of Christmas future standing on the grave of Ebenezer. In an election where you’re hearing one candidate talking about the future vs. the past, I can tell you that in their eyes fracking — the extraction method that produces the fuel that fires this nation — is the past.
The progressive elements of our politics have been consistently clear about their position for years, but now that your votes are so crucial to them, suddenly fracking is acceptable to them. From someone who has lived it, I can promise you, it’s not. A future of no bans but limitations, hold ups, and strategic regulatory maneuvers will bring you the same fate my home has suffered, with the same effects.
Pennsylvania holds the future
Pennsylvania, you hold the future of energy in your hands. No one will be in a position to set policy on these issues unless you put them there. I can tell you, from states away, that the future of your signature industry is critical to mine and families all across this country.
We share a heritage of making sure that for Americans the lights come on, the house is warm, and that the future is bright. After years of regulatory aggression, that future is limited for my part of the world, but for you it doesn’t have to be.
The Keystone state can always be the cornerstone of American energy, and all the way from the Bluegrass state I sure hope you’ll keep it that way.
Derek Jorge Campbell is an attorney in private practice and serves as County Attorney for Perry County in southeastern Kentucky.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.