Des­pite huge en­thu­si­asm for shift­ing from fos­sil fu­els to green en­ergy, this tran­si­tion just isn’t hap­pen­ing. Im­ple­ment­ing a sig­nifi­cant change in our cur­rent tra­jec­tory would be pro­hib­i­tively ex­pen­sive. A ma­jor pol­icy over­haul is needed.

On a global scale, we are in­vest­ing nearly $2 tril­lion an­nu­ally to cre­ate an en­ergy tran­si­tion. In the last 10 years, so­lar and wind power use has reached un­prece­dented lev­els. How­ever, this in­crease hasn’t led to a re­duc­tion in fos­sil fuel con­sump­tion. In fact, fos­sil fuel use has grown dur­ing this pe­riod.

Numer­ous stud­ies show that add­ing re­new­able en­ergy adds to en­ergy con­sump­tion in­stead of re­plac­ing coal, gas or oil.

More green en­ergy, more emis­sions

Re­cent re­search re­veals that for ev­ery six units of new green en­ergy, less than one unit dis­places fos­sil fu­els. Anal­y­sis in the United States shows that re­new­able en­ergy sub­si­dies of­ten in­crease to­tal en­ergy con­sump­tion. In es­sence, pol­i­cies de­signed to boost green en­ergy lead to more emis­sions.

Advertise with us

Human de­mand for af­ford­able en­ergy is in­sa­tia­ble, as it un­der­pins ev­ery facet of mod­ern life. In the last 50 years, en­ergy de­rived from oil and coal has dou­bled, hy­dro­power has tri­pled, and gas has qua­dru­pled. Mean­while, there has been a sig­nifi­cant rise in nu­clear, so­lar and wind en­ergy. Con­se­quently, the avail­abil­ity of en­ergy has reached un­prece­dented lev­els glob­ally.

The at­tempt to drive a green en­ergy tran­si­tion mainly re­lies on the as­sump­tion that heav­ily sub­si­diz­ing re­new­ables will drive fos­sil fu­els away ef­fort­lessly. A re­cent study chal­lenged this no­tion, find­ing that dur­ing ev­ery pre­vi­ous ad­di­tion of a new en­ergy source, it has been “en­tirely un­prece­dented for these ad­di­tions to cause a sus­tained de­cline in the use of es­tab­lished en­ergy sources.”

Look­ing back fur­ther into hu­man­ity’s his­tory, the cur­rent strug­gles with green en­ergy should be no sur­prise. Dur­ing the 1800s, as so­ci­et­ies moved from wood to coal, over­all wood con­sump­tion in­creased as coal be­gan to meet a larger share of en­ergy needs. Sim­i­larly, when tran­si­tion­ing from coal to oil, by 1970, the com­bined en­ergy con­tri­bu­tions from oil, coal, gas and wood were more sig­nifi­cant than ever be­fore.

What causes us to change our rel­a­tive use of en­ergy? One study in­ves­ti­gated 14 shifts over the last five cen­tu­ries, such as when the ag­ri­cul­tural in­dus­try shifted from plow­ing fields with an­i­mals to fos­sil fuel-pow­ered trac­tors. The main driver has al­ways been that the new en­ergy ser­vice is ei­ther bet­ter or cheaper.

Solar and wind fail

Solar and wind fail on both counts. Un­like fos­sil fu­els that can pro­duce elec­tric­ity when­ever needed, so­lar and wind can pro­duce en­ergy only ac­cord­ing to the va­ga­ries of day­light and weather. And they are not cheap. At best, they are com­pet­i­tive on price only when the sun is shin­ing, or the wind is blow­ing at just the right speed. The rest of the time, they are mostly use­less and in­finitely costly.

Advertise with us

Fac­tor­ing in the cost of just four hours of stor­age, wind and so­lar en­ergy solu­tions be­come un­com­pet­i­tive com­pared to fos­sil fu­els. A sus­tain­able tran­si­tion to so­lar or wind would re­quire or­ders of mag­ni­tude more stor­age, mak­ing this goal en­tirely un­at­tain­able.

More­over, hu­man­ity has still not found green en­ergy solu­tions for most of our trans­por­ta­tion needs — think of planes and freight — and we ha­ven’t even be­gun a tran­si­tion to the vast en­ergy needs of heat­ing, man­u­fac­tur­ing or ag­ri­cul­ture. Solar and wind are en­tirely de­ployed in the elec­tric­ity sec­tor, which makes up just one-fifth of all global en­ergy use. We are deal­ing with a small part of a vast chal­lenge and ig­nor­ing all the “too hard” prob­lems like steel, ce­ment, plas­tics and fer­til­izer.

It should be no sur­prise that — de­spite much rhet­o­ric sup­port­ing an en­ergy tran­si­tion — even the Biden ad­min­is­tra­tion ex­pects oil, gas and coal will keep in­creas­ing up to 2050, even as re­new­able en­ergy sources dra­mat­i­cally in­crease.

Achiev­ing a gen­u­ine tran­si­tion away from fos­sil fu­els would ne­ces­si­tate mas­sive sub­si­dies for green en­ergy, stor­age solu­tions and al­ter­na­tive tech­nol­o­gies like hy­dro­gen. It would also re­quire sub­stan­tial taxes on fos­sil fu­els to make them less at­trac­tive. The man­age­ment con­sult­ing firm McKin­sey & Co. es­ti­mates that the cost of such a tran­si­tion would ex­ceed $5 tril­lion an­nu­ally, with the ac­tual eco­nomic ef­fect po­ten­tially be­ing five times higher due to its im­pacts on eco­nomic growth.

For res­i­dents of wealth­ier na­tions, this could trans­late to $13,000 per per­son yearly — an ex­pense un­likely to be po­lit­i­cally fea­si­ble.

Advertise with us

Failed strat­e­gies

A more prac­ti­cal ap­proach would be to en­hance green en­ergy tech­nol­o­gies sig­nifi­cantly. This in­volves in­creased in­vest­ment in re­search and de­vel­op­ment for re­new­able en­ergy, stor­age solu­tions, nu­clear power and other al­ter­na­tives.

Reduc­ing the cost of these green solu­tions be­low that of fos­sil fu­els is es­sen­tial for wide­spread global adop­tion, not just in af­flu­ent, cli­mate-con­scious coun­tries.

When pol­i­ti­cians tell you the green tran­si­tion is here and we need to get on board, they are ask­ing vot­ers to con­tinue bank­roll­ing in­vest­ment in failed strat­e­gies that don’t ad­dress the un­der­ly­ing prob­lems. A more in­tel­li­gent ap­proach is needed to en­sure that green en­ergy tech­nol­o­gies be­come vi­a­ble and widely ac­ces­sible.

Bjorn Lomborg is the president of the Copenhagen Consensus Center, a visiting fellow at the Hoover Institution, and the author of “False Alarm.”