Donald Trump often asserts that during his term as president, “we had the greatest economy in history.” Polling evidence suggests that a significant number of voters believe this claim.
But the notion that Trump somehow had a positive influence on U.S. economic growth and employment is unsupported by fact. Trump inherited a thriving economy and left the country in significantly worse shape, conditions from which we are only now recovering.
From Obama to Trump
The pre-COVID economy that some may remember as strong existed principally during the first two years of Trump’s presidency, reflecting trends continued from the Obama administration.
As NBC News reported during the 2020 presidential campaign, comparing Trump’s first the key economic indicators from Trump’s first three years in office to Barack Obama’s second term shows “a continuation of trends (that) suggests Trump didn’t build something new; rather he inherited a pretty good situation.”
Indeed, the most consistent issue that candidate Trump raised in 2016 was the country’s allegedly anemic economic growth rate, which was under 3% a year. Trump asserted that the U.S. economy, buoyed by his tax cuts, would grow at least at a 3% annual rate, but he predicted that “it could go to 4, 5, and maybe even 6%, ultimately.”
Nowhere close
Yet President Trump got nowhere close to those numbers. The 2.5% average quarterly economic growth rate under him was about the same is it was during Obama’s second term. The best annual growth rate achieved was 2.9% in 2018, but it fell to 2.3% for 2019, before the pandemic hit.
Read More
Nonetheless, the growth that started when Obama was president and continued on the same trajectory into 2019 was enough for Trump to call it the “greatest” ever. By comparison, the most recent data available, for the second quarter of 2024, show the U.S. economy during the Biden Administration growing at an annual rate of 3%, higher than the average quarterly rate during the Trump years.
In 2016, Trump also assailed “America’s job creation deficit,” pegging it at “well over 20 million jobs.” When Trump took office, however, the unemployment rate was already well into a multi-year decline, having peaked at 10% in October 2009 and fallen to 4.7% at the end of Obama’s presidency, a very low figure by historical standards.
In fact, Obama saw a much steeper drop in unemployment in his second term (a decline of 3.3 percentage points), than Trump did in his three pre-pandemic years, a total decline of 1.2 points. On average, more jobs were added each month during 2013 through 2016 than were gained in Trump’s non-pandemic years from 2017-2019 (215,000 vs. 182,000).
Fewer jobs
By the end of Trump’s term, the economy had actually lost a total of 2.7 million jobs and the unemployment rate had increased to 6.4%. By comparison, under the Biden administration the unemployment rate as of August 2024 has declined to 4.2%, below where it stood at the beginning of 2017.
Trump had declared specifically that he would “bring back” the U.S. manufacturing sector. But by the end of his term the number of persons employed in the manufacturing sector he’d promised to revive had actually fallen from 12.36 million to 12.19 million. Since then, under policies adopted by Biden, employment in the manufacturing sector has rebounded by more than 6% to almost 13 million jobs.
Given Trump’s track record, there is no reason to trust his current boast that he can produce better results in the future. He’s made that claim before and failed to deliver. As his current running mate, Sen. JD Vance, noted in February 2020: “Trump has just so thoroughly failed to deliver” on his economic program.
David S. Keir is a lawyer practicing in Washington, D.C., specializing in telecommunications regulation.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.