The nearly $15 billion sale of U.S. Steel to Nippon Steel Corporation has stirred significant controversy. But the truth is, if the Nippon deal is blocked, U.S. Steel will likely relocate its operations to another state — something no Pennsylvanian should want to see happen.
All signs point to U.S. Steel eventually closing shop in Pennsylvania. They’ve made it clear from the beginning that they don’t have the financial means to modernize their facilities here. Instead, they’ve chosen to build a new plant and create jobs in Arkansas rather than invest in Pennsylvania.
Nippon Steel Corporation has agreed not only to purchase U.S. Steel but to honor the current union contracts, to invest more than $1 billion in the Mon Valley Steel Mill and to keep the company’s board and management majority American.
While it is understandably hard for “steelers” like me to accept that U.S. Steel may potentially be sold, the acquisition discussions with the local steelworkers’ union have been productive: Local union leaders have done a tremendous job of working with and obtaining commitments from Nippon to upgrade, invest and keep the jobs here in southwestern Pennsylvania.
Politics in the way
The real threat to this deal is coming from President Joe Biden, who may block the sale through the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States, citing national security concerns. But not a single major economic or foreign policy expert has echoed these concerns.
More than that, Pennsylvania is no stranger to foreign-owned companies with union workers. The Elliott Company, a major employer in my Westmoreland County district, is owned by Japan’s Ebara Corporation. Japan is one of America’s most reliable allies.
Blocking this sale only harms Pennsylvania workers and families. National politicians don’t care which state U.S. Steel operates in: They govern the whole country. But Pennsylvania officials should care. Only after public pressure did Gov. Josh Shapiro and Lt. Gov. Austin Davis come to the table. KDKA radio reported that Mr. Shapiro is meeting with union leaders to try to broker a deal that the Biden-Harris Administration can accept.
I hope he is successful, because the alternative is grim: Manufacturing, including steel, is still and always will be the backbone of Pennsylvania’s economy. But it is also late: While Mr. Shapiro tested the political winds and stayed out of the fray, it was local union leaders who fought tirelessly to maintain workers’ livelihoods. The governor should have been fighting for our state from the start.
Never again
Despite its struggles and decision to focus its investment elsewhere, U.S. Steel is a significant part of our heritage and with that comes an unrivaled, experienced and innovative workforce that helped build America. It is part of who we are and part of who I am.
My dad lost his job when the steel industry tanked in the 80s. He lost everything and never fully recovered from those losses. We can’t allow history to repeat itself. We can’t let what happened to my family happen again to our region and to our steelworker families. Not ever.
We must not allow misguided politicians or special interests to make decisions that harm our communities. Nippon has made clear commitments that must be taken into account. Baseless fearmongering cannot win the day. We must hold our elected officials accountable to ensure that Pennsylvania’s steelworkers can continue to thrive.
This is more than a business deal. This is a fight for the future of our region, our workers and our identity. Like choosing between the Steelers and the Browns, I’ll always pick the Steelers — just as I’ll always stand with the people who built America.
Sen. Kim Ward, R-Westmoreland, is the president pro tempore of the Pennsylvania State Senate.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.