A proposition: Most cliches are largely true. Idle hands are the devil’s workshop. Want something done, you should ask a busy person. One door shuts and another door does open.
But most conventional wisdom is wrong. Kamala Harris turned out not to be an airhead. Joe Biden is not too old to be president. Donald Trump was not changed by a near-death experience.
The wrongness of conventional political wisdom in the wake of the two political conventions is stunning. For how many years have we been told that conventions don’t matter any more? Or that vice presidential choices don’t?
The Democratic convention mattered greatly. It re-introduced Vice President Harris to the nation. And we discovered that everything we thought we knew about her was false.
She is not a lousy politician. She is an incredibly smart and savvy politician. She is not an elitist or a snob but an egalitarian. She is not a flake, but disciplined and clear headed.
And the keepers of conventional wisdom, the pundits, are almost always mistaken. That’s how we got Donald Trump.
The pundits didn’t see that the middle of the country had had it with the Clintons, globalism and NAFTA. Trump would not have defeated Joe Biden in 2016.
And not for nothin’: Turns out that Donald and Hillary agree about his base. She calls them “deplorables.” He calls them “basement dwellers.” Maybe they are tragically uninformed.
Echo chambers
I have been listening to podcasters lately. I had great hope for podcasts — maybe they would be the new, new journalism.
Wrong. It’s the same old stuff, or worse — inside baseball, the game, and smug all-knowing membership in the inner ring. These folks are clever and they do cover technique well. But they are mostly former campaign operatives and PR types who interview each other.
They have created new echo chambers. Supremely self-satisfied ones. They know little of history or ideas, and care only a little about policy. Yet they are utterly supercilious and smug.
They are good at calling the game. But they don’t help us to better understand the game, as John Madden did football. And they fail utterly to explain the stakes.
They told us Kamala was a cipher. Now they love her. They love Tim Walz, too, because he is not like them.
He’s a middle American Dad who can actually do politics himself, in a perfectly natural way — as an expression of his own values and character.
Kind of like Joe Biden. The man the elites and media trashed.
Forgiveness and remembrance
Ironically, Donald Trump was the “democratic” nominee this year. He beat, and beat down, everyone in his party. The “people” (primary voters) of his party were for him.
Ms. Harris was nominated by party elders, an elite — in a party that, since 1972, has claimed to be radically democratic. Oops.
There is still a modern smoke-filled room. It is not composed of big city mayors and governors — traditional bosses, who picked well back in the day. It is composed of Nancy Pelosi, George Clooney and the editorial board of the New York Times.
Yes, Mr. Biden is old and fragile and maybe too tired to campaign effectively. But also wise and capable. And he won the primaries — 14,465,519 votes. If Ms. Harris prevails, all will be forgiven. History will forget Ms. Pelosi and Mr. Clooney.
But what happened to Joe Biden was not right and should be remembered. And his ability to put country — defeating Trump — over self is remarkable and also worth remembering. Mr. Biden’s grace and good sportsmanship are way beyond what Barack Obama or Bill Clinton would have been capable of in his shoes.
Forward and backward
Our journalism is actually more devoid of substance than our politics. Where is the Lewis Lapham, the I.F. Stone, the Meg Greenfield or Murray Kempton of today? Where are the public intellectuals, like Reinhold Niebuhr, Hannah Arendt, David Reisman, Russell Kirk and Mary McCarthy?
It turns out that conventions mattered in 2024. Ms. Harris had a chance to define herself. Not just to be crowned but to tell us what she is about.
Mr. Trump told us what he was about, at his convention, too. In no uncertain terms: Strong-man, populist Christo-authoritarianism. But the press, like the courts, have been unable to handle Trump. They treat him as if he were normal. They have not successfully connected Trump to Mussolini, Khomeini or Savonarola.
Mr. Biden, Ms. Harris and Mr. Walz were heroes at their convention. They rose to the moment like nothing we have seen in politics since FDR met the Great Depression.
Ms. Harris and Mr. Walz also found their message: We are not going back. Forward, not backward. However haltingly. Into life; into history.
Charles Peguy said that modern life begins in mystery and ends in politics. Our goal should be the opposite: Start in politics; end in thought.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Turn off the Republican ads and listen to Harris and Walz.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.