The Supreme Court did America a favor by ruling that ex-presidents cannot be prosecuted for their official acts after they leave office. Admittedly, this is a very broad immunity that, in theory, puts the President above the law. Nor was this decision a very convincing interpretation of the Constitution.

But the decision still did our country a favor.

Dangerous path

America had been sliding down the dangerous path of prosecuting political opponents. This started with Republican calls to “lock her up,” directed at former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton during the 2016 Presidential election. Despite his threats, Trump never prosecuted her.

Then came actual criminal prosecutions of former president Donald Trump for actions taken before, during and after his term in office. Whatever their legal merits, these prosecutions alleged serious wrongdoing by Trump.

Advertise with us

If the immunity decision had not been rendered, it seems clear that a newly elected President Trump would have ordered the criminal prosecution of Joe Biden, the man he calls “crooked Joe,” even though there is no evidence Biden has engaged in criminal conduct.

Now, given the breadth of the decision, a prosecution of Biden is impossible.

Some countries have seen prosecutions of political opponents without losing their freedom but I’m not sure constitutional democracy in America would have survived this slide. The immunity decision may have saved American constitutional democracy.

There is a cost to this. Future Presidents will not have to fear criminal prosecution after they leave office. Legal experts have been busy describing potential presidential criminal wrongdoing since the immunity decision was announced.

But, prior to Trump, America got along perfectly well for 234 years without prosecuting an ex-president for conduct in office. None of the other checks on Presidential power were affected by the immunity decision. Presidents are still subject to congressional investigation, public opinion and, at the extreme, impeachment and removal. The vague threat of future criminal prosecution never added much to those deterrents.

Advertise with us

Nor does Trump himself get off scot-free even with the decision. The New York State conviction for falsified business records involves conduct undertaken before Trump was elected and should be unaffected. There may be other problems with that conviction, however.

Similarly, on the other side, the documents case against Trump overwhelmingly concerns actions taken after Trump left office and should also be unaffected by the decision. That case remains Trump’s clearest criminal violation.

Complex cases

The federal and Georgia cases against Trump for trying to overturn the 2020 presidential election are considerably narrowed by the immunity decision. In fact, they may have been nullified. But these cases were weaker than people realize.

The worst thing that Trump has done — the action that makes him a traitor to the Constitution and unfit for office — is that alone among all the candidates for president in American history, he refused to accept the will of the voters. Trump lied about the result, pronouncing the 2020 election stolen and convincing millions of Americans that American democracy is a fraud. The damage he has done is incalculable.

And yet, even if you could prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Trump knew he was telling lies — a doubtful proposition without Trump taking the stand — lying about an election is simply not a crime. Trump is not charged with lying about the election by itself.

Advertise with us

The second worst thing that Trump has done was his plan to intimidate Vice President Mike Pence into rejecting valid Biden electors and sending the election result back to sympathetic Republican-dominated state legislatures.

This is treated as a crime in Trump’s indictment and it is true that Pence lacked authority to reject Biden electors. If he had done so a court presumably would have stopped him.

But rejecting electors had never before been treated as a crime. Numerous members of Congress, from both parties, have voted to reject valid electors over the years. No one thought that was a crime.

Trump did point the mob to the Capitol. But his words that day did not amount to incitement to violence. That is probably why Trump was not charged with insurrection.

Trump pressured state officials to investigate voting fraud claims. But if Trump knew they were false, he also knew the investigations would not change the vote.

Advertise with us

Finally, Trump did conspire with the so-called false electors — private citizens who filed false documents claiming to be genuine Trump electors. This is also a part of the criminal case against him.

What case?

But what was the crime exactly? I could file an official document naming myself King of England. That would be a minor crime. But it would not make me King. These false electors could not affect the election result unless the courts allowed the election to be returned to the states. But then it would have been legal.

Convictions in these two cases were never assured. Any conviction might well have been overturned. The immunity decision may prevent even a trial. But these cases were never going to matter as much as some people hoped.

Bruce Ledewitz is a professor of law at the Thomas R. Kline School of Law of Duquesne University. His previous article was “The system's not made for workers.” The views expressed do not represent those of Duquesne University.