Just two summers ago, the Supreme Court tore away 50 years of reproductive rights, ripped a half century of settled abortion law out by the roots and sent states scrambling to manage or tragically mismanage the collective incoherence of the Dobbs decision.

On Monday, we found out the Court was just warming up. You think that was some “activist” judging? Well watch this.

Remember that foundational American tenet that no one is above the law, its overture composed in the Declaration of Independence and its full symphony delivered throughout the Constitution of the United States? Well, funny story.

The funny story

Seems a New York real estate con artist turned failed gameshow host who’s now a 34-times convicted felon asked the Supreme Court if the President of the United State might actually be above the law, and the esteemed justices have pretty much agreed. That notion that equal treatment under the law goes back 248 years to the founding of the republic and is intrinsic to our national identify, well that is like, so 18th century.

Advertise with us

Any number of legal scholars have weighed in since the Court, in Trump v. United States, essentially rewrote the Founding Fathers to assist the 45th president in his ceaseless, tortured legal and extralegal crusade to avoid the slammer and regain the White House in the process. But if you could distill all of it into one reaction to illuminate the emergency, try this from J. Michael Luttig, the noted conservative jurist and former U.S. Circuit Court judge.

“It can never again be said that in America, ‘no man is above the law,” Judge Luttig wrote on X, formerly Twitter. “The Supreme Court held today that the President of the United States — and the former president in particular — is above the law, and the only person in America who is above the law.”

He went on to tell Media Matters for America, “Our democracy and the rule of law are what had made America the envy of the world and the beacon of freedom to the world for almost 250 years now. Today, the Supreme Court cut that heart and soul out of America, holding that the former president is immune from prosecution for any of his actions in and around Jan. 6, taken in his so-called official capacity as President of the United States.”

Joe Biden responds

So as you probably suspected, something really bad had happened Monday morning when the Court’s final fusillade of pre-vacation judgments were posted. Something so bad that it demanded an immediate reaction from the White House, where the guy who somehow lost last week’s presidential debate to a firehose of lies was busy with a very different issue.

Joe Biden’s problem in the moment was the sudden lack of clarity on a question that needs an immediate consensus from him, his family, his presidential campaign, and from any Democrat anywhere who might influence a resolution: Is Biden the only Democrat who can beat Trump in 2024, or is Biden the only Democrat who can lose to him?

Advertise with us

That question will have to stew for a few more news cycles, but it can’t withstand a month of hand-wringing.

If you thought Biden seemed feeble in the debate, as some 72% of voters did in one poll, his comments in the aftermath of Trump’s Supreme Court were a second illustration in five days of a president failing to meet the moment.

“This nation was founded on the principle that there are no kings in America and that each of us is equal before the law,” Biden noted some nine hours after the decision dropped. “With today’s Supreme Court decision on presidential immunity, that fundamentally changed for all practical purposes. (The decision) almost certainly means that there are virtually no limits on what a president can do. This is a fundamentally new principle and it’s a dangerous precedent.”

Biden kept at it for five full minutes without ever indicating what he might do with his newfound immunity, whether he might enforce his own code of ethics on a Court beholden to oligarchs, whether he might expand the Court to 13 to reclaim some ideological balance, whether he might insist on term limits, whether he might initiate any reform for a body where three of the nine justices were installed by Trump and the dark forces who cherish the former Buffoonatic-in-Chief’s special brand of kakistocracy.

So don’t elect Trump

What Biden said instead was essentially a warning not to elect Trump, especially now that presidential power is pretty much unlimited. Well, no kiddin’.

Advertise with us

It was only last December that a trial judge and a three-judge appellate panel ruled unanimously that Trump could be prosecuted for Jan. 6 and its conspiracy. In Judge Tanya Chutkan’s ruling, she was compelled to note that the office of the president “does not confer a lifelong ‘get-out-of-jail-free’ pass.”

Why would the Supreme Court even take a case in which an American would argue that he couldn’t be prosecuted because he’s above the law?

I guess it sounds plausible to people who have placed themselves above the law.

Gene Collier is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: gcollier@post-gazette.com and on X: @genecollier. His previous column was “The 2024 Presidential debates: Must we?”.