An involuntary commitment is a legal procedure initiated when a person poses a “danger of harm” to themselves or others, compelling them to receive psychiatric treatment against their wishes. It’s a well-intentioned effort to help someone in the throes of a psychiatric emergency, but one that may cause serious, unintentional harm.

A drastic intervention that should be a last-ditch approach, it should be rarely employed, and then only with utmost care and caution. But how often is it used by police and other authorities? Is it always used well?

Sparse data

We don’t yet know enough to say definitely. Sparse county-specific and State Police data obtained via Right-to-Know requests raise concerns about the frequency with which involuntary commitments are used, the process of authorizing commitments, and their effectiveness.

Right-to-Know requests revealed that the involuntary commitment rate varies dramatically among Commonwealth counties: from roughly 120 to 305 commitments per 100,000 residents annually. Allegheny County’s was 278 in 2022, with 3,430 people being involuntarily committed that year.

Advertise with us

This raises a series of questions: Why is there such stark inconsistency in involuntary commitment rates among counties? Is the Commonwealth meeting residents’ mental health needs in a way that minimizes crises? And, when a mental health crisis arises, is compulsory treatment via involuntary commitment effective?

Answering those questions requires transparent data. But few Pennsylvania counties can or will provide the critical statistics. While half of American states already publish involuntary commitment data, Pennsylvania lacks an official count of yearly commitments, let alone the robust information on patient demographics and diagnoses necessary to assess effectiveness.

Governor Shapiro’s Executive Order 2023-20, which established the Behavioral Health Council, does not address data transparency despite its stated objective to develop “a statewide action plan ... to deliver timely and quality mental health and addiction care services, in a culturally relevant, trauma-informed, and recovery-oriented manner, through an evidence-based behavioral delivery system.”

Pennsylvania’s opaque involuntary commitment procedures obstruct accountability for policymakers, providers, citizens, and the people subjected to involuntary treatment.

Data driven tools

At present, only extreme involuntary commitment cases involving violence garner media attention. A prominent example from Centre County was the 2019 death of Osaze Osagie, who was killed by State College police while they served an involuntary commitment warrant. Such appalling events trigger community outcry and cause policymakers to investigate and promise change.

Advertise with us

However, data-driven policy and transparency often fall by the wayside once attention abates. Case in point: Centre County officials pledged in 2020 to create “a data collection, repository, and sharing system to be used for evaluating the effectiveness of the current [mental health] system.” Yet, as of 2024, they’ve made no progress on the promised system.

This does not have to be the case. Following a 2012 mass shooting at the Western Psychiatric Institute, Allegheny County audited and then altered its emergency mental health tracking system.

The audit helped establish the Allegheny County Mental Health Involuntary Commitment: Interactive Dashboard. This real-time, publicly accessible system uses court and county administrative records (rather than patient electronic health records) to introduce transparency into the county’s emergency mental health care services.

The data captured by Allegheny County’s system has generated eye-opening findings. For example, within five years of an emergency psychiatric evaluation — even without a commitment — one in five patients die. In addition, 34.3% of involuntary commitments initiated by Allegheny County police are overturned following compulsory transport and physician evaluation.

Moreover, Black individuals are overrepresented in the involuntary commitment population: While Black individuals represent 13% of the county’s population, they account for 32% of commitments within the county.

Advertise with us

Data-driven tools, such as the Allegheny County Dashboard, create transparency, encourage accountability, and help better serve those at risk. The resulting data can identify systemic biases, engage citizens, and be employed to develop just, evidence-based mental health policy. Thus, collecting and publishing meaningful, de-identified involuntary commitment data should be the rule, not the exception.

The needed state-wide system

The Pennsylvania Department of Human Services and the Pennsylvania State Police already have mechanisms for collecting involuntary commitment data from county officials. The Allegheny County Dashboard is further evidence that a state-wide data system is feasible.

It is incumbent on the Behavioral Health Council, elected officials, public health officers, and police forces to institute a publicly accessible, transparent, data-driven system that provides annual reports on involuntary commitments within the Commonwealth. Pennsylvanians deserve a just and effective mental health system — especially when they are in crisis.

Ari Gluckman is a research assistant at Penn State and an advanced EMT in Centre County. Michele Mekel is the associate director of the Bioethics Program at Penn State with a joint appointment to the Humanities Department at Penn State College of Medicine. Laura Y. Cabrera is the director of the Neuroethics Lab and the Dorothy Foehr Huck and J. Lloyd Huck Chair in Neuroethics at Penn State.The Allegheny County dashboard can be found here.