Nearly every weekday, while the Downtown subway is closed for repairs, I walk from the Post-Gazette’s North Shore newsroom to Smithfield Street to pick up the bus. From the Fort Duquesne Bridge to Point State Park to Market Square, I’d rate it one of the best urban promenades anywhere — though I wish the city would follow through on the Peduto-era plan to pedestrianize Liberty Ave.
But when I reach Smithfield, everything changes. There are people muttering to themselves and men screaming obscenities at every woman who walks by. Crumpled bodies are passed out — I hope — in doorways. Young faces withered by drugs and trauma float along, aimless and hopeless.
Commentators and officials who insist that Downtown has turned the corner are right — about certain parts of Downtown at certain times of day. My wife and I recently went to dinner and a show in the Cultural District, and Penn Ave on a Saturday evening was a portrait of urban exuberance.
But those who insist Downtown has descended to dystopia are also right, especially up and down Smithfield, which not long ago was supposed to be refreshed and rebranded as Pittsburgh’s Main Street. Now, tourists and shoppers and office workers can feel like trespassers in a sad, wild and possibly dangerous country.
The complicated reality of Downtown means that neither mayoral happy-talk nor media sensationalism capture it fully, nor do they help. Rather than trying to categorize Downtown as simply good or bad, healthy or sickly, safe or dangerous, I’d rather ask a more fundamental question: What does it mean for a place to thrive?
Failure to thrive
It means a place where people, visitors but especially residents, thrive. But what does it mean for people to thrive?
Some would say there’s no answer, because thriving looks different for everyone. But no one actually believes that. No one believes a person in the throes of acute fentanyl addiction is thriving, or that someone who can’t resist screaming at women on the street is thriving.
I’d offer this definition of human thriving: actively progressing toward some purpose, goal or vision of the good life. A thriving place attracts thriving people, and helps them in pursuing some good: sociality, work, play, learning, art and so on.
To be clear, there are numerous reasons beyond one’s control that one might struggle to thrive, including structural injustices, untreated mental illness and being chronically surrounded by other non-thriving people. Failure to thrive does not in itself indicate a personal moral fault.
But a society that creates, or allows to be sustained, places and communities hostile to human thriving is at fault.
An anti-society
It’s popular among Pittsburgh’s elected and unelected activists to say that anyone who is troubled by public drug use or frightened of being accosted by the seriously mentally ill is a coddled, contemptible suburbanite (spiritually, if not by residence). This is both morally wrong and politically unsound.
What one experiences in some parts of Downtown is more than the typical messiness of urban life — beyond the mostly harmless dysfunction that’s endemic to cities and that opens our eyes to the diversity of others’ experiences and struggles. At a critical mass, this dysfunction becomes a kind of anti-society, ordered only to chaos and actively hostile to everyone’s thriving.
That means there’s nothing wrong with being repelled by the Smithfield scene — in fact, you probably should be. It’s not about judgment or contempt or hatred for the ill or addicted. Quite the opposite. It’s about honestly recognizing a place and a community that are working against their ability to thrive, to pursue once again some vision of the good life, for them as well as the city.
Real compassion
Such a place becomes antithetical to the very idea of a public space. It is often said that for a place to be truly public, it must be free to be used by anyone, but this isn’t correct. Some uses of public areas — say, injecting drugs or screaming obscenities — make those places inaccessible and inhospitable to others. It’s up to the public authority to restore them to the public.
This is why most people, indeed the vast majority of people, will never consider the Smithfield scene acceptable or even tolerable. Some may be malicious and want to see struggling people come to a bad end, but most understand that the life the people on the street are living is bad for them, and for everyone.
I’m not proposing any particular policy, and I’m definitely not suggesting a law enforcement-first approach. Everything from the city’s Reaching Out On The Streets health care facilities to Second Avenue Commons to Catholic Charities’ new Compassion Corner have a role to play in giving struggling people a place to be that’s better for everyone than the streets, and giving them hope of thriving again.
But first, we need to agree that the status quo is intolerable, not because the people on Smithfield are bad, but because Smithfield is bad for them.
Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.