It’s commencement time on campus and therefore time for the chattering classes to chew their cuds. The former president of Harvard writes: “Everything and nothing is at stake in a commencement address. Maybe you have already heard it eight times. Maybe there was nothing worth hearing in the first place.”
But, she continued, “perhaps you will encounter a speaker who, even in this tumultuous spring, can reach across the chasm of innocence and experience separating graduates and the person talking to them. The old endeavor to imagine themselves young and look through fresh eyes again; the young begin to imagine themselves old, as they will become all too soon.”
Wowzers. That’s a tall order. Bridging the chasm of innocence and experience? Everything and nothing?
Fraught times
The times do seem tumultuous and fraught. We again face a presidential choice no one much likes. The Middle East is afire. Emmanuel Macron warns of Russian aggression and expansionism and the rise of a tribal and fantasy-prone right.
Half of this country thinks the economy is in the tank, though the stock market booms and unemployment is lower than it has been in most of our lifetimes. The Trump “hush money” trial proceeds apace — part melodrama, part burlesque.
And our leaders? Our leaders? A woman who wants to be vice president writes a book in which she brags of meeting foreign potentates and dictators she has never actually met and of killing her dog. Who kills a puppy and boasts?
Read More
Hannah Arendt was right. There is something bottomlessly dumb about much evil. And something evil in all profound stupidity.
Oh, and Bobby Kennedy’s son, he who would elect Trump (and for what?), says a worm ate part of his brain. Perhaps he is preparing his excuses for the day he has to meet his father in the great beyond.
And Kristi Noem should spend the rest of her life shoveling out kennels.
What would one say at commencement? What could one say?
What to say?
Maybe first try not to bridge chasms.
Maybe say one or two small, simple things, from the heart.
Keep it short. I have become something of a connoisseur of bad sermons and it is amazing how less bad the shorter ones are. Lincoln spoke simply at Gettysburg. And briefly.
One possible topic would be higher education: Today’s campus protesters share much with the protesters of the 1960s. They are ersatz idealists who don’t know too much or think very clearly, and they tend toward stridency and self-righteousness.
But they see injustice and want to rise up against it. And that’s a decent start.
Former U.S. Labor secretary Robert Reich, a wise commentator and savvy economist who teaches at Berkeley, has done his own informal investigation of current campus protests. He believes there is a small sliver of antisemitism, but that most student protestors are sincerely outraged at the disproportionality and excesses of the Netanyahu military and the loss of innocent life in Gaza.
Sincerity is a start, too.
Sadly, many of the 1960s activists gave up. Better to burn out.
How about this as a commencement message to the young? Pace yourselves, but hang on to your outrage. Arm yourselves with history and with the ability to make distinctions. Defend humanity, not a side or tribe. Attack governments and leaders, not peoples.
The universities have failed the student activists of both past and present. We need to teach students how to think and how to work. Prepare them for life, not entitlement. For that they need languages and literature, not postmodernism, gender theory or media studies.
Another speech could be about our politics. It keeps getting meaner and narrower. The media has lost sight of issues and policy as it focuses on Mr. Trump’s demons and Mr. Biden’s physical fragility. And the country has lost sight of the country.
Nobody seems to worry much about the fate of the republic. What kind of country does Mr. Biden, or Mr. Trump, want? What kind of government?
I vote for “everything” being at stake. But, again, in small doses.
My commencement address
I’d say two things.
First, seek some larger purpose in your life. “Seek what is above.” The religious impulse is in all of us. Perverted, it can become leftist intolerance or Trumpist facism.
Liberal education, values education, and critical thinking can help you find your path. Modern life can swallow us all in function and administration and the tyranny of electronic distraction. Find a way to, in some part of your life, seek what is above.
Second, everyone needs to make a living. This involves compromise. But try, as best you can, for some kind of balance between career and creativity; commerce and joy.
Every job, and every profession, must retain a core integrity but also delight.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “We wanted an activist Supreme Court and now we don't.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.