Some years ago, on a sum­mer eve­ning in a leafy neigh­bor­hood of Wash­ing­ton, D.C., an ed­i­tor of the New Re­pub­lic was walk­ing his dog, and he came upon for­mer sen­a­tor Eugene McCarthy, a neigh­bor, who was walk­ing his dog.

The writer was trou­bled about the pend­ing pres­i­den­tial elec­tion and felt, as we all seem to, qua­dren­ni­ally, that the choice was a poor one — it should never have come to this.

They walked along, and talked of pol­i­tics and its in­her­ent lim­its. McCarthy said: “You vote for the man. In Amer­ica, you vote for the man.”

You vote for the man

And that makes me think of the small scan­dal in my fam­ily when my mother, who came from deep Demo­cratic roots and mar­ried a man with the same sort of roots, be­came an en­thu­si­ast for the pres­i­den­tial cam­paign of Nel­son Rocke­fel­ler — she even at­tended a rally in Co­lum­bus, Ohio. My father re­garded it as bi­zarre; in­ex­pli­ca­ble.

Advertise with us

And my friend the late Su­san­nah B. Hatt, an aris­to­cratic New En­glander, a trans­la­tor, ar­chae­ol­o­gist, and vol­un­teer in the early days of the hos­pice move­ment — uber-ac­com­plished. And, po­lit­i­cally, all over the board. She went from Nor­man Tho­mas to Dwight Ei­sen­hower to Sen. McCarthy him­self (the afore­men­tioned Gene), to Jesse Jack­son. She cam­paigned ac­tively for each of them and gave real money.

How could she move from Tho­mas, the so­cial­ist, to Ike, the gen­eral? Well, maybe a lit­tle hero wor­ship. But, mostly, ad­mi­ra­tion of char­ac­ter.

You vote for the man. Or woman. Be­cause char­ac­ter is ev­ery­thing. And coun­try comes be­fore party. And po­lit­i­cal slo­gans are half truths. But also half lies. And ide­ol­ogy is the dis­ease of col­lege kids, zeal­ots, and Euro­pe­ans.

Amer­i­cans used to un­der­stand that pol­i­tics is like any other prac­ti­cal en­ter­prise — a fam­ily, a busi­ness, a church. One makes pru­den­tial and tem­po­rary judg­ments based on val­ues, yes, but also in­stinct, econ­o­mies, and the sur­prises of life.

The best com­pass on those seas is not slo­gan or ide­ol­ogy, but char­ac­ter.

Advertise with us

This pre­cept was once fun­da­men­tal to the Amer­i­can po­lit­i­cal tra­di­tion: char­ac­ter trumps. It mat­ters most. A first class tem­per­a­ment beats cha­risma, a good pro­gram, even ex­pe­ri­ence, which also mat­ters, or should.

Think of our great­est pres­i­dents: Wash­ing­ton, Lin­coln, both Roosevelts. Their pol­i­cies and pro­grams moved us for­ward but the pol­i­cies and pro­grams came from their val­ues, formed and re­fined by char­ac­ter.

Part­ies and plat­forms don’t cre­ate char­ac­ter and val­ues. They are cre­ated by them.

Fight­ing for his life

All this makes me think of Ohio, U.S. Sena­tor Sher­rod Brown, said to be in the fight of his life to hang on to his seat.

Mr. Brown has been in Ohio pol­i­tics for 50 years. And he has al­ways been him­self, his own un­pack­aged, un-“han­dled” self — rum­bled, grav­elly-voiced — unique. And that in­cluded, most im­por­tantly, his val­ues.

Advertise with us

He has con­sis­tently been de­voted to peo­ple who don’t have much money or power. He has walked with them, lis­tened to them in union and VFW halls, and tried to fig­ure out prac­ti­cal ways to em­power them.

He has never had the an­ger or sweep of rhet­o­ric of Ber­nie Sanders or Eliz­a­beth War­ren. He’s never been a de­mo­nizer. He’s al­ways been a re­tail pol­i­ti­cian. On TV he looks iron­i­cally amused and tired.

And Mr. Brown’s leg­is­la­tive goals have been mod­est but real: Help for in­jured vet­er­ans; caps on in­ter­est for stu­dent loans; low­er­ing the cost of in­su­lin.

Per­haps more than any mem­ber of Con­gress, Mr. Brown un­der­stood the toll of usury on the work­ing class, the poor, and the young. This was a mostly los­ing but no­ble cause.

Prac­ti­cal fixes are hard. Real prog­ress, harder. Leg­is­lat­ing is like sculpt­ing in snow. There are 100 ways to be a sen­a­tor and 50 ways to be a good one. And jour­nal­ists don’t have good tools of mea­sure­ment and of­ten set­tle for gos­sip and herd wis­dom.

Advertise with us

But I know that when his party em­braced the global econ­omy, Sher­rod Brown said “no,” and stood for lo­cal econ­o­mies and Amer­i­can work­ers and cars and suits made here.

Pro­tec­tion­ism might mean pro­tect­ing the work and life of a neigh­bor. It might be about the dig­nity of work. Through the years, Mr. Brown has qui­etly stood firm.

Two more things about Sher­rod Brown: First, he knows how to talk to peo­ple, with re­spect. He greets ev­ery per­son the same way — di­rectly, sin­cerely and kindly. Second, he reads books and thinks about them. That’s a feat for any Amer­i­can, but es­pe­cially a pol­i­ti­cian.

All this equals char­ac­ter.

Go back to the per­son

And if Mr. Brown is turned out on a Trum­piam wave in Ohio, it will sim­ply be the tri­umph of slo­gan and half-baked ide­ol­ogy. We are caught up in pos­tures — wo­ke­ness on the left and MAGAism on the right. Nei­ther of which has any re­al­ity or in­tel­lec­tual se­ri­ous­ness.

Advertise with us

We need to get back to the man, the woman — the per­son. Char­ac­ter is all.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “It's Trump and McConnell against politics.”