Sev­eral states have re­moved Don­ald Trump for the pres­i­den­tial pri­mary bal­lot per Sec­tion 3 of the 14th Amend­ment, i.e. that oath-break­ing in­sur­rec­tion­ists may not hold pub­lic of­fice. On Mon­day, March 4, the Supreme Court unan­i­mously over­turned Col­o­rado’s ac­tions on this mat­ter.

Five of the nine Justices went fur­ther, stat­ing that it is the US Con­gress that has the power to en­force the Amend­ment. Four of the nine dis­agreed with this un­char­ac­ter­is­tic and need­less de­par­ture from ju­di­cial re­straint by the Court to speak to a mat­ter which is not be­fore it.

Cor­rup­tion or cow­ard­ice?

Justices So­to­mayor, Kagan, and Jack­son said that the ma­jor­ity “de­cide novel con­sti­tu­tional ques­tions to in­su­late this Court and pe­ti­tioner from fu­ture con­tro­versy.” Amy Coney Bar­rett also dis­agreed with the ma­jor­ity.

I per­son­ally won­der to what ex­tent that in­su­la­tion for the pe­ti­tioner, Don­ald Trump, is cor­rup­tion. I also won­der to what ex­tent that in­su­la­tion for the Court is cow­ard­ice.

Advertise with us

The mi­nor­ity elab­o­rated with sim­ple and un­de­ni­able rea­son­ing that Sec­tion 3 of Amend­ment 14 is “self ex­e­cut­ing, mean­ing that they do not de­pend on leg­is­la­tion.” The ma­jor­ity re­sponded in the pen­ul­ti­mate para­graph of the unan­i­mous opin­ion: “So far as we can tell, they ob­ject ...”

The un­char­ac­ter­is­ti­cally pet­u­lant phrase, “So far as we can tell,” can only be un­der­stood to mean that the justices think what the mi­nor­ity states makes no sense, even though the mi­nor­ity’s ar­gu­ments are both com­pel­ling and un­con­tested.

The ma­jor­ity’s state­ment can only be un­der­stood as a per­sonal at­tack, of the type which is made so com­monly by men against women. Coin­ci­den­tally in this case, the mi­nor­ity is all women and the ma­jor­ity is all men.

Ev­ery­one is watch­ing our justice sys­tem, both here in Amer­ica and world­wide. Don­ald Trump faces trial for mul­ti­ple crimes in both fed­eral and state courts.

Tens of mil­lions are convinced that he is a great leader who has been tar­geted by cor­rupt pros­e­cu­tors and pol­i­ti­cians. Tens of mil­lions more are convinced that he is a dan­ger­ous crim­i­nal who must be stopped.

Advertise with us

The im­mu­nity ques­tion

The Supreme Court will hear oral ar­gu­ments the week of April 22 on the ques­tion, “Whether and if so to what ex­tent does a for­mer Pres­i­dent en­joy pres­i­den­tial im­mu­nity from crim­i­nal pros­e­cu­tion for con­duct al­leged to in­volve of­fi­cial acts dur­ing his ten­ure in of­fice.”

The Court has cho­sen to de­lay that hear­ing nearly two months. Some have claimed that they want to sup­port Don­ald Trump’s in­ter­est in de­lay­ing the crim­i­nal tri­als he faces, but I think there is a more likely rea­son.

The Con­sti­tu­tion says noth­ing what­ever re­gard­ing the Pres­i­dent’s crim­i­nal li­a­bil­ity for his ac­tions while in of­fice. The ab­sence of any guid­ance from our Con­sti­tu­tion on how crim­i­nal acts by our Pres­i­dent will be han­dled is a fun­da­men­tal flaw in our na­tions’ great­est le­gal au­thor­ity. That buck stops with the Supreme Court, and it’s an ex­tra­or­di­nar­ily weighty and dif­fi­cult one.

I don’t think it’s rea­son­able to fault the Court for giv­ing them­selves time to thor­oughly con­sider the is­sue, the ex­ist­ing body of law and ju­di­ciary opin­ion, the pe­ti­tioner’s briefs due March 19, and the briefs in sup­port due April 8.

The only res­o­lu­tion

If Pres­i­dent Trump com­mit­ted the crim­i­nal acts of which he is ac­cused, and that two month and more de­lay in justice proves to be justice de­nied, I think we must ac­cept that as a price we pay for a pro­foundly flawed Con­sti­tu­tion.

Advertise with us

The sim­ple fact is that the only path to a peace­ful res­o­lu­tion of the di­vi­sions in Amer­ica sur­round­ing Don­ald Trump is the 2024 Pres­i­den­tial elec­tion. The mar­gin of vic­tory must be clear, one way or the other, and the in­teg­rity of the elec­tion must be clear too.

Don­ald Krieger is a bio­med­i­cal re­searcher whose fo­cus is the elec­tric ac­tiv­ity within the brain. He lives in the Pitts­burgh area.