The Supreme Court has just one veteran (Samuel Alito) sitting on the bench today. That’s a shame, because as the court prepares to rule on the former president’s claim of “absolute immunity” in Trump v. United States, there are lessons it could learn from veterans like myself.

Military personnel have a duty, and even an obligation, to disobey unlawful orders. Under national and international law, service members are entitled not to carry out orders if they violate the Constitution, even when they come from a direct superior.

Which is why I’ve been so alarmed at the threat to the rule of law posed by the former president’s claim, and surprised at the court’s apparent willingness to entertain it as a serious possibility.

Compare Trump with Nixon

“Absolute immunity” isn’t a claim that I thought I’d hear invoked by any politician in my lifetime. I remember Richard Nixon, and the sense of shame and pressure — even from his fellow Republicans — that led him to resign the office when it became clear that he had lost the nation’s confidence. Contrast that with Trump’s immunity claim, which would effectively place any president above the law for acts committed while in office.

Advertise with us

This is antithetical to the conservatism I grew up with, which stood for the Constitution, the rule of law, equal justice, and accountability. Those who wear the uniform do it not for recognition or public acclaim, but to support and uphold the constitutional democracy that we swear our oaths to.

That’s what led 19 former national security leaders to file a brief in this case arguing that granting Trump's claim would imperil not only our democracy, but would empower authoritarians here and around the world.

Taken to its logical conclusion, as the former president’s own lawyers admitted in court, the “absolute immunity” argument would clear a president to order SEAL Team Six to assassinate his political rivals. There is nothing conservative — or even American — about this.

And to the special operators who would be tasked with carrying out such an order, it’s the textbook definition of an unlawful one.

Immunity and power

It is useful, though, as a means of showing just how far the argument’s proponents are willing to go in advancing their case for an unfettered vision of power for the presidency.

Advertise with us

“Absolute immunity” would be bad enough on its own. But it’s being paired with a much broader, more expansive plan for the president to be able to exercise unprecedented power over all areas of the federal government.

We should call “absolute immunity” what it is: an argument for the president to be above the law. It’s not only a dangerous argument; it’s a shortsighted one too. Because if the court grants it, even in part, presidents of either party will be empowered to use it as a shield against accountability for any acts committed while in office.

This would leave us in a very scary place, with nothing more than an individual president’s character — a very thin reed in many cases — to rely on as a final bulwark against unchecked executive authority.

As a conservative and a veteran, I can’t sit by while these arguments are being put forward by those who purport to speak in my name.

Living by the oath

The principles set forth in my military oath mirror those from the presidential oath taken by candidates of either party: fealty to the Constitution, support for the rule of law, and a pledge to support and defend American democracy from enemies foreign and domestic. “Absolute immunity” makes a mockery of these values.

Advertise with us

The court is of course free to take all facts and circumstances into consideration as it prepares to decide this case. But, in the absence of more veteran voices on the court, of people who understand what it means to live by this oath, it should also consider a time-honored tenet of military service: an unlawful order has no standing under our system.

Justice is blind, and presidents aren’t kings. No one is above the law — or, at least, no one should be.

Julian Wynnyckyj lives in Pittsburgh, PA. He is a member of Republicans for the Rule of Law.