It was late in the night, about 11 p.m. as the story goes, when Robert B. Carnahan heard a loud rap at the door of his home at 322 Collins Ave. in East Liberty. Outside, standing on the front step, was the newly appointed chief of the Department of Public Works of Pittsburgh, Edward Manning Bigelow.
He must begin packing at once, he told Carnahan. There was no time to waste if he was going to catch the 2:30 a.m. train for New York.
Beating the developer
It was these two men, perhaps alone, who understood the great significance of the moment. Information had just arrived that an agent representing the syndicate of John J. Howley, Real Estate had boarded an earlier train bound for New York with intention of then securing passage to England for a personal visit with Mrs. Schenley.
It had been well known to both of them that Mrs. Schenley was intent on parting with a portion of her Pittsburgh holdings and had been receiving numerous lucrative offers from real estate syndicates to purchase her land, particularly the Mt. Airy tract in Oakland, which comprised almost 200 acres of the “choicest building land.”
Months prior in fact, Bigelow had suggested to Carnahan that he travel to England to open negotiations with Mrs. Schenley on behalf of the city to purchase land for park purposes. Carnahan had objected, not seeing what was to be gained by traveling to Europe.
He reassured his colleague that “we can effect a purchase just as easily by correspondence as personal visit,” and it was decided that Bigelow would prepare a communication to Mrs. Schenley. The letter, dated August 1, 1889, had received a promising reply, but now, after more than three months without having secured a deal both men knew that the time had come to take decisive action.
Carnahan hurriedly prepared for his journey, his family frantically searching the house for enough cash to put in his money belt. What was going through his mind in this moment can only be imagined. At age 65, he likely had reservations about making the long and unexpected journey, but as a member of Bigelow’s Committee on Parks and as Mrs. Schenley’s trusted legal advisor — he had great influence on her — he knew he must be the one to go.
An accomplished lawyer who had served as District Attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania under Presidents Lincoln, Johnson, and Grant, he was accustomed to accepting the burdens of a great challenge. Amiable and honest were words often used to describe him and his “warm-hearted, helpful and sympathetic disposition” made him the perfect man for the job.
After arriving in New York by the early train he boarded the Linder that same day. At a stop in Cobh, Ireland, the experienced traveller caught passage on a mail boat to England, thereby gaining several hours. Upon arriving in London, he hurried to Mrs. Schenley’s residence and was there admitted at once for a personal interview. He had beat the land agent at his own game.
Mrs. Schenley’s beneficence
When he arrived back in New York nearly three weeks to a day later, on Nov. 5, 1889, the news was immediately wired back to Pittsburgh with expectant joy. “A WOMAN’S BENEFICENCE — Mrs. Schenley Makes A Million Dollar Gift — Four Hundred Acres Assured for Pittsburgh’s Park,” read the headline in the Pittsburgh Post.
There were many battles yet to be fought and many decisions of consequence to be made in order to make the park a reality, but Robert Carnahan had successfully played his part. He had completed the all-important mission and as a result, the future of Pittsburgh and its residents would be changed forever.
Eric Michalski, a resident of Munhall, is writing a book on the beginning and early years of Schenley Park.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.