On his 70th birthday, in 1997, Daniel Patrick Moynihan sat for a “Meet the Press” interview with Tim Russert. Russert asked his old boss if he was disappointed in Americans’ fading sense of the efficacy of government. Pat Moynihan knew well both the practical and conceptual limits, but he also believed deeply in government’s capacity to make life better.

The GI Bill put Moynihan through college and graduate school. It made his whole life possible — from shoeshine boy in Hell’s Kitchen to Harvard professor to ambassador to the U.N. and United States senator.

Well, yes, Moynihan said. He’d come to the government in the administration of John F. Kennedy. He did miss the hope and the promise. But, he said, he was content. He had a wonderful family, many friends and “it’s a great country.”

Missing conviction

Advertise with us

Here’s what I miss: The broadly shared conviction that America is a great country, no matter how politics or government may be perceived as disappointing.

One of the TV talking heads intones solemnly that the nation has “soured on Biden,” as if this is something real — like war, floods, fires and famines, all of which are quite present in the world at this moment and legitimate reasons for despair.

Those who know they know told us once that the country had tired of Jerry Ford, Jimmy Carter, George Herbert Walker Bush. All good men, we figured out later. A notch better than we’d earned.

Our restlessness reminds me of a woman my wife and I knew years ago who announced she was divorcing her stunned husband. “He’s a good man and a good father. But I can do better.”

She didn’t.

Advertise with us

And the country will not do better than Mr. Biden.

We have become a nation of malcontents. We ask not what we can do for our country but what it can do for us. And left and right feed the culture of complaint.

A friend of mine says of millennials, “don’t get me started.” He calls them an entitled and ungrateful generation. But it’s not just the young who are ungrateful and entitled. It’s all of us. It’s the whole society.

Yet the World War II “greatest” generation, and the Korean War generation that followed them, were not this way. Not at all. Why did they, who lived through the Great Depression and war, find it so easy to be grateful and so natural to serve?

Another friend answers: because they knew true want and danger. When you have been in a bread line you are immeasurably grateful for good food. When you have been alone and in peril in a strange land, you are grateful for home.

Advertise with us

My parents’ blessings

My late mother-in-law was endlessly nostalgic for the work she did as a teen in her hometown during World War II, in a factory converted to munitions manufacturing instead of supporting the local economy. She went to school and worked another job as well. She did her bit for the war effort.

My father disliked most of the jobs he had in the Navy, but was immensely proud to have served during the Korean conflict. Veterans Day, for him, was a solemnity.

He was an ardent Democrat, union man and Catholic, who hated bullies and rooted always for the quiet people. But he didn’t like the 1960s much. Oh, he liked V-8 engines and wide ties. But he didn’t like the idea that the country was broken — that something was terribly amiss and needed to be fixed. And that is the predominant attitude today.

My Dad was an innately grateful human being. He understood life and fatherhood as miracles. But he was also grateful by conviction. A job, six kids clothed and schooled, two cars in the garage – these were not his due but his blessings. He had grown up in a family of five children sleeping in one room. Now he had a house with five bedrooms.

Advertise with us

We said grace every night.

One of Pat Moynihan’s books is called, “Counting Our Blessings.” It’s not hard to count once you start. The bounties of American abundance are innumerable: Thick socks. Strong tea. National parks. Dog parks! You can call up your favorite aria from “Messiah,” or a song by Sixto Rodrigeuez in seconds.

The Bill of Rights is a pretty great blessing. So is the courage of the Freedom Riders. And prophetic American mavericks, now mostly forgotten. People like Shirley Chisholm, and I.F. Stone, and Russell Kirk.

America off the grid

America off the grid and unobserved is a blessing — people talking football and cars; two guys at Starbucks debating the term “organic cotton”; an old man reading a folded newspaper at a lunch counter.

Advertise with us

For a country well understood is well loved.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “The Republicans don't offer America hope.”