Some recent articles, editorials, and op-eds have raised concerns about the impact of a third-party candidate in the 2024 presidential election, an election that for Democrats and Republicans looks increasingly like a Biden-Trump rematch.

Like many Americans — Democrats, Republicans, and Independents — we believe that another four years of former president Trump would be an unacceptable outcome of the next election. But we also read the polls. Americans would like different candidates on both sides: two-thirds of voters don’t want a rematch of 2020.

Most of these pieces argue that a third candidate would be a spoiler and allow Trump to win. They go on to criticize the efforts of No-Labels, an organization working to get ballot access for an alternative ticket.

No Labels, a 501c4 non-profit organization founded in 2010, is committed to encouraging bipartisan, practical solutions to our nation’s problems. No Labels was instrumental in the creation of the House Problem Solvers Caucus, a bipartisan group currently led by Brian Fitzpatrick (R-PA) and Josh Gottheimer (D-NJ) and has continued to support the work of Caucus as it seeks to implement thoughtful policies to address key issues facing the country, including recent initiatives on the debt ceiling and the federal budget.

Advertise with us

No Labels has become increasingly concerned that extreme partisanship, most recently demonstrated in the battle over the election of House Speaker, will prevent the Congress from implementing responsible solutions to the serious problems facing the country. Neither party seems very interested in doing the work of government or serving the people’s interests but rather both are focused on the factions within the parties and preserving their power. Both parties need to accept responsibility for the morass.

Because of the partisanship and disfunction as well as the electorate’s level of dissatisfaction with former President Trump and President Biden, No Labels has worked to obtain ballot access in all 50 states to create an “insurance policy” unity ticket – one that includes both a Republican and Democrat —  to be selected at a convention next spring. No Labels has committed to running the ticket only if it has a clear path to victory. As active members of No Labels and Pennsylvania voters, we want to address the key concerns of critics.

First, commentators assert or assume that a third presidential candidate cannot win. Recent polling results show that this assertion is simply wrong.

The data suggest Trump is viewed favorably by about half of Republicans, who are about 36% of the electorate. That means that 18% of the electorate, i.e., Republicans who are not solidly for Trump, is up for grabs. Again, using recent polling data, Biden seems to be solid with about 40% or so of Democrats. Since about 37% of the electorate is blue, 15% of the electorate is solidly behind Biden but another 22% is up for grabs — Democrats who are not solidly for Biden.

About 27% of the electorate is not affiliated with either party. Polls suggest only 10% of those individuals supports Biden or Trump; call that 3% of the electorate, leaving about 24% of independents uncommitted. When you add that 24% to the Republicans and Democrats in play, the total is nearly two thirds of the electorate who are not hard-core Biden or Trump supporters. Would these individuals prefer a bipartisan ticket that is committed to formulating and enacting the solutions favored by most Americans to our nation’s problems? We think they would and that a third candidate can win.

Advertise with us

But, let’s assume that the third candidate doesn’t win. Critics assert that a No Labels ticket would simply act as a spoiler, throwing an election to Trump that otherwise would be won by Biden. The numbers don’t support that assumption either.

Very consistent polling data over the last months suggests both Biden and Trump have an unfavorable/disapproval rating of about 55%: both lack broad-based support. Given the strong negatives of both candidates, an alternative ticket could draw more voters away from Trump and throw the election to Biden.

Finally, our discussion has focused on overall percentages and thus the popular vote. As we know, the election will be won or lost in states like Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and North Carolina, which can and do swing between red and blue. Recent polls put Trump ahead in five of the seven key swing states.

Given the fact that current polling data suggests that Biden could very well lose to Trump even without a third candidate, perhaps the question should not be whether a No Labels ticket will be a spoiler, but rather whether it rescues the election from a Trump victory by providing a choice that the voters actually want.

We support No Labels because we have concluded that our national government is failing to address the serious issues facing the country and instead has been immobilized by partisanship. If the traditional parties are not able or willing to provide candidates who are viewed positively by most Americans, we support No Labels’ right to provide alternatives who are. We look forward to individuals from across Pennsylvania joining us in this effort.

Michael Schwartz is CEO of New Wave Energy Capital Partners in Squirrel Hill. Lawrence Feick is Professor of Business Administration at the University of Pittsburgh.