John Henry Newman, saint and poet, hated what he called “unreal” words. “Let us guard against frivolity, love of display, love of being talked about, love of singularity, love of seeming original. Let us aim at meaning what we say, and saying what we mean; let us aim at knowing when we understand a truth, and when we do not.”
I thought of Newman when I read British political scientist Brian Klaas recently: “American journalists have become golden retrievers watching a tennis ball launcher. Every time they start to chase one ball, a fresh one immediately explodes into view, prompting a new chase.”
Following social
I get daily updates on my news feed on Tom Brady’s love life, I guess because I watch football. If you are looking for a topic less germane to the good of the republic, or any human being in the republic, good luck.
So many words on social and public media are unreal. We want distraction. We are addicted. We are programmed for trivial pursuit. The mainstream media, as a matter of marketing and out of laziness and confusion, now follows social media.
It should be the other way around, of course. But there is a demand for blather and cant. Journalism (definition to follow), not so much.
The problem of modern people is the inability to get real, to face reality, to go to the heart of our worries and ourselves. Despite decades of introspective sociology, psychology, and ersatz spirituality.
Perhaps the last 100 years — the sheer rate of change and humanity’s capacity for dehumanization — have worn us out.
Yet, when we needed the stability and consolation of institutions and traditions to deal with this exhaustion, we went in the opposite direction and tossed many of those traditions and institutions away.
What now?
So what now? First, we must try to recover some of those traditions and institutions and our reverence for them. I am thinking of family life, religious practice, liberal education (the best that has been thought and said), and truly liberal democracy.
Practices as simple as family meals together and grace before meals, could change us, help us. Interestingly, there is a nascent youth movement toward Orthodox and Evangelical Christianity, Judaism, and even Islam, afoot today.
And then we need to get back to the thing itself, the real: Grown food instead of processed food; workers instead of “influencers”; experience instead of posture.
Years ago, I heard a lovely tale, perhaps revised and refined in retelling, about the great Robert Penn Warren when he was teaching at Yale. He met a student on the steps of the library and asked him what he was working on.
The student said a paper on e.e. Cummings and then showed the professor a raft of books on the subject. The poetry of Cummings was not among them. Read Cummings, said Penn Warren.
But we want cliff notes for life and history.
Tell stories
Penn Warren wrote:
“Tell me a story.
In this century, and moment of mania,
Tell me a story.
Make it a story of great distances, and starlight.”
The thing, not the theory. The writer, not the commentator on the writer.
I have been watching documentaries of late. Too many become visual term papers. Puddings without themes. They merely rehash events or lives. They forget to seek insight.
And one reason is the dreaded “talking head;” the expert — the same species that has corrupted journalism.
The best moments of most documentaries are when the subjects themselves speak.
Talking heads are the tennis ball machine.
You cannot tell any story through it.
When we lose the capacity to speak and think clearly, we lose sight of our credal values, we splinter and fight, we lose love of liberty for all.
“We have no press in this country,” said a despairing friend. One wise editor says we have two presses: The right-wing press, which cares nothing for truth, and the lame legacy press, which is too timid to look for truth.
Lame legacy press
But the legacy press is not lame because it tries to be impartial. To the contrary. It is lame because of trivial pursuit. Since Theodore White, David Broder and their imitators in the 1960s, the elite press has been obsessed with the game. Who are the winners and losers in politics and society?
So the press writes about the Senate dress code, instead of Donald Trump’s call for the death of Gen. Mark Milley. Tennis balls, instead of reporting on profound contempt for decency and the American idea.
Golden retrievers giving chase. Or, “blackbirds on a telephone line,” as Sen. Eugene J. McCarthy described the press: “As one flies away, they all fly away and when one comes back they all come back.”
“Journalism,” said George Orwell, “is printing what someone else does not want printed. Everything else is public relations.”
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Mitt Romney's last chapter: building a new party.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.