Last week, Republican Dave McCormick announced his candidacy for the United States Senate. If nominated by the Republican party, he’ll run against Democrat incumbent Bob Casey Jr.
Whichever wins, even if their party takes all three branches of government, chances are that no policy they propose will become law. Why? Because of the toxic interaction of partisan polarization and the Senate filibuster.
Partisan polarization
Neither party will have anything close to a supermajority in the Senate after the 2024 election. And given the intensity of partisan polarization today, the minority party is never especially willing to cooperate with the majority party. Why help give the other side a major policy win when your own voters hate those guys across the aisle and see compromise as betrayal?
Because the filibuster imposes a de facto 60-vote requirement to pass anything through the Senate (apart from the narrow 50-vote carveout for “budget reconciliation”), very little legislation has a real chance of passage. No party can command a supermajority, and there are rarely enough minority party members willing to lend a hand to help the majority reach that magic number of 60.
It doesn’t have to be this way. Democrats want to scrap the filibuster wholesale. But the filibuster can foster meaningful debate and deliberation. A simple reform would keep it without instantly sending just about every bill to the legislative graveyard.
Read More
Our proposal is simple: bills supported by a majority of senators in two successive Congresses can pass the Senate. (We described it in detail in the journal National Affairs.)
Two tracks
In effect, our proposal creates two tracks for passing a bill through the Senate. Track one preserves the status quo: if a bill enjoys a 60-vote supermajority, debate can be immediately ended and the bill can be passed.
Track two provides an alternative route for passing legislation. A bill that commands a majority but doesn’t enjoy supermajority support could be provisionally passed. After the next election, the Senate could formally pass it by a second simple majority vote.
A bill that can’t clear a supermajority won’t automatically die. It will just have to command a simple majority twice, in two successive Congresses.
This reform would give senators and citizens alike the time to consider and debate bills that are consequential yet controversial. Unlike a wholesale repeal of the filibuster, this wouldn’t allow partisans to quickly ram legislation through the Senate.
If a party is trying to pass something without the other party’s support (i.e., via a simple majority as opposed to a supermajority), it will have to convince voters that it’s right. If voters agree — and thus allow the majority party to retain its power by voting for that party’s candidates in the next election — the majority party will have earned the right to do some legislating. Conversely, the voters may instead reject what the majority party has to offer by “voting the bums out.”
Real-world consequences
By opening the door to more legislation, this proposal could help repair the damaged feedback loop of American politics. It would help ensure that elections have real-world consequences that voters can judge as good or bad — and then vote in the next election accordingly. In addition, our reform will help elections revolve around real issues and policies again.
Instead of being about abstract grievances and issues that don’t really affect real life, elections will center on the most consequential pieces of pending Senate legislation. Why? Because the stakes will be higher: if the majority party were to retain its power, it would have a real chance to pass laws.
That’s not the case now, when our politics is more of a game — some twisted form of entertainment — than a serious business. Candidates and voters have reacted accordingly.
Thomas Harvey and Thomas Koenig are students at Harvard Law School.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.