With news bubbling about the possibility of impeachment proceedings being launched by Republicans against the Democratic President Joe Biden, it is a good opportunity to talk about how one Pittsburgher actually caused the first impeachment trial of an American president. 155 years ago, a Republican majority in the House of Representatives impeached the Democrat President Andrew Johnson.
Johnson’s treatment of his Secretary of War, Pittsburgh attorney Edwin Stanton, had provoked the Republicans in the House to vote to impeach the president.
The issue of the day
Edwin Stanton grew up in Steubenville, Ohio, and came to Pittsburgh in 1847 as a young man in his thirties. It was here that he became a highly sought after attorney, establishing a very profitable law business.
He soon found himself tapped by fellow Pennsylvanian President James Buchanan to become his attorney general in December 1860 in the final, fateful months of Buchanan’s administration. He’s credited with pushing Buchanan to resist Southern demands as they threatened secession. When Lincoln was elected in November 1860 and the dye was cast for the South to secede, Stanton was back in private practice, but in January, 1862 Lincoln invited Stanton to become his Secretary of War.
Andrew Johnson had succeeded Abraham Lincoln after that fatal night at Ford’s Theater. Suddenly this pro Union southerner from Tennessee was catapulted into the presidency. Stanton agreed to continue to serve under Johnson as his Secretary of War. At first Stanton and Johnson got along, but as the months passed and the issue of the “reconstruction” of the South became the issue of the day, the gulf between the president and his Secretary of War only widened.
Read More
As Johnson vetoed one civil rights bill after another and refused to support the proposed 14th amendment, Stanton, who had begun his career as a Jacksonian Democrat, became increasingly aligned with the Radical Republicans in Congress. The Republicans favored much greater protections and rights for the newly freed slaves and a harsh policy toward the South before they could be readmitted into the Union, all of which Johnson stubbornly opposed.
Johnson was a strong states’ rights advocate and was committed to the rule of white men only. He, like many in the South and the North too at the time, did not support Black civil rights let alone their right to vote.
Impeaching Johnson
In light of Johnson’s vetoes of civil rights legislation, Congress passed the Tenure of Office Act, which prevented the president from firing anybody in his administration who the Senate had approved. This presumably protected Stanton. But after more than two years, Johnson finally had had it with Stanton and in August 1867 sought to replace him.
The Republicans in Congress argued that as a result, the president had violated the newly passed Tenure of Office Act and urged Stanton to remain in his office. Stanton, feeling that he couldn’t abandon the cause of the Republicans, holed up in his office for eight weeks, sleeping on the couch and having food brought to him. Using this stand-off as a pretext, the Republican majority in the House passed an impeachment resolution claiming that the President had violated the law and should be held accountable.
The grounds for impeachment are based on the proposition that the government official might be guilty of “treason, bribery and other high crimes and misdemeanors,” as it says in our Constitution. The charges against Johnson never met this rigorous standard. Instead, he was impeached because the Republicans didn’t like his policy of pandering to the Southern secessionists, of refusing to play hard ball with a South that was trying to restore white domination over the newly freed slaves.
The Senate, while they may have agreed with the Republican policy position, did not believe that Johnson’s actions met the high bar set out in the Constitution. So they voted not to convict.
High standards
In our own bitterly divided time, it would appear that the possible impeachment of President Biden is a political Hail Mary by Republicans looking for a way to retaliate against a President they claim has weaponized his Justice Department against former president Trump. Let’s hope that on this occasion as well, the high standards of the Constitution are followed — and that there is no impeachment, let alone conviction.
Barbara Burstin (burstin@pitt.edu), who teaches history at the University of Pittsburgh and Chatham University and has written a biography of Pittsburgh mayor Sophie Masloff, is doing research on a book entitled “Nineteenth Century Pittsburgh VIPs who you probably have never heard of.” Her previous article was “Pittsburgh’s first version of Doug Mastriano.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.