Between 2010 and 2020, rural America saw its first-ever population decline, a trend mirrored in Pennsylvania’s rural counties. This decline was evident despite Gallup poll data from the end of that decade showing considerable interest among Americans in residing in rural areas. Almost one-third of Americans expressed this desire in December 2020.
Our research team, supported by a grant through the Center for Rural Pennsylvania, examined the factors influencing people’s decisions whether to relocate to rural areas and how these align with strategies to counteract the shrinking population of rural Pennsylvania.
The rural appeal
The survey asked questions about people’s attachment to a place; their living preferences; their thinking, willingness, and intentions about moving to rural areas; individual economic factors (e.g., employment) and non-economic factors (e.g., healthcare access) related to moving to rural areas; their perceptions of rural Pennsylvania; and their choices on hypothetical incentives to move to rural areas.
Interestingly, a sizeable fraction (ranging from 15% to 25%) of respondents from other states and nonrural areas within Pennsylvania indicated a detachment from their current locations, hinting at a potential openness to relocating. The allure of rural living held substantial appeal, with approximately 25% of participants from both groups expressing a preference for living in such settings.
Married individuals, those raising school-aged children, remote employees, those burdened with student loans, and those leaning conservatively in their political beliefs all showed an increased inclination toward rural living. A strong K-12 education system, ample opportunities for outdoor recreation, and a more laid-back lifestyle were top attractions. On the flip side, factors such as immediate access to primary healthcare facilities and a varied food scene did not rank as highly in influencing their decisions.
Read More
An unexpected discovery was the perception of rural Pennsylvania among its own residents. Those living in the state harbored a marginally more negative view of the rural parts of Pennsylvania than participants from other states.
Both groups, when thinking about rural Pennsylvania, predominantly visualized farms. Native Pennsylvanians also visualized forests and mountainous terrain.
Lastly, in terms of incentives that might encourage someone to move to rural Pennsylvania, state residents demonstrated a strong preference for a 10-year state income-tax credit as opposed to a direct relocation grant.
The right circumstances to move
Our research shows that many people in both the non-rural parts of Pennsylvania and neighboring states might consider moving to rural areas under the right circumstances. To harness this potential, we recommend the following policies.
First, targeted marketing. This involves the design and implementation of marketing and incentive schemes that cater specifically to individuals whose characteristics indicate a likelihood to relocate.
Second, community development. This means aligning community growth strategies with the most influential reasons people are drawn to or repelled from a location. This entails weaving together the lifestyle benefits associated with rural living and aligning them with viable job opportunities, ensuring that newcomers see the appeal in the region they’re thinking about.
Third, ensure varied representation. The term “rural” encompasses a wide range of landscapes and lifestyles, especially in a diverse state like Pennsylvania. Programs and events should showcase the multifaceted nature of what “rural” signifies, thereby broadening the perception and appeal of rural Pennsylvania.
Fourth, offer tailored incentives to ensure that the incentives resonate with potential movers. Reassessing current incentive schemes and modifying them based on unique community requirements can make them more successful.
Promising Prospects
Fifth, strengthen local government. Addressing the issue of population decline requires robust local governance. Collaborating with state-level networks and tapping into university expertise can equip local governments with the tools and knowledge to address their challenges.
Finally, boost civic engagement. The best community-development plans are those in which residents have a say in how things get done. Including current residents in the formulation of community-growth strategies not only ensures that the plans are in tune with local needs but also deepens residents’ connection and commitment to their surroundings.
While challenges persist, the prospects for reversing the shrinking of Pennsylvania’s rural population could be promising — if we think about why people would move and use tailored strategies recognizing the nuances of rural living preferences to encourage them.
Bing Ran is a professor at the School of Public Affairs at Penn State Harrisburg. Joseph Hafer is an assistant professor in the department of public and nonprofit administration at the University of Memphis. Their study used a cross-sectional online survey from late 2022 to early 2023 of almost 4000 people sourced from Pennsylvania and ten neighboring states via Amazon Mechanical Turk.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.