Americans seem to own an awful lot of guns — approximately 400 Million, according to the latest estimates. Why do so many Americans — women as well as men — need or want to own so many guns? More importantly, is it known what role mere gun ownership has in gun homicide rates? We need to know that before any wholesale banning of guns or classes of guns, as the result may not reduce firearm homicides.
Gun ownership in the United States is legal, with the Second Amendment of the U.S. Constitution obviously the most cited guarantor of this right. The Supreme Court of the United States has long precedent of upholding this right to gun ownership. Importantly, it has also found a Federal and State interest in at least some reasonable gun control measures.
Reasonable people can disagree on reasonable measures. Yet it seems both sides are so polarized and confident in their respective positions that a reasonable, meaningful agreement may never be reached, an agreement that both safeguards gun ownership and reduces gun related homicides.
Samuel Hazo, for example, ruminated on these same questions in a recent opinion article titled “In America, there will never be a farewell to arms.” He asks: “What is it about guns that makes them particularly attractive to some men?”
He cites a few possible motives and concludes the root cause most likely lies in what he calls an “American machismo.” He, perhaps aptly, emphasizes the frivolity of this fatal attraction by quoting poet William Matthews’ characterizing guns, as “the jewelry of men.”
But not so fast. Apparently, for American women, diamonds are no longer a girl’s only best friend. No longer are guns just for men.
Read More
Gallup reports that the latest data, from three years ago, show that 22% of women report owning a gun. The number of men who own guns stayed the same, around 43%, from 2007 to 2022, while the percentage of women owning guns rose from 13% to 22%. Whether the significant rise in women gun ownership points to something other than machismo as the underlying factor in determining gun ownership in the U.S. is uncertain.
So the number of Americans who have guns is high. Does owning a gun raise the chances of using that gun to kill?
A 2013 study seemed to show “a robust relationship between gun ownership and firearm homicide rates.” However, the researcher admitted “we could not determine causation.” Yet this correlation between gun ownership and homicides is not frivolous. It points to a possible cause.
Many believe that Americans are unlikely to change their gun-loving ways very much in the future. But there does seem to be ample cause for optimism, however slow the pace of change.
The research shows that “the prevalence of gun ownership decreased by about 36%” from 1981 to 2010. Specifically, “By decade, this percentage declined from 60.6% in 1981 to 1990 to 59.6% in 1991 to 2000 to 52.8% in 2001 to 2010.” These trends are encouraging.
Even more recently, Pew Research reports that 2021 had the highest number of gun deaths in American history, but notes that the statistic does not take into account the growth in population. “On a per capita basis, there were 14.6 gun deaths per 100,000 people in 2021 — the highest rate since the early 1990s, but still well below the peak of 16.3 gun deaths per 100,000 people in 1974.”
Perhaps America’s future is not so dangerous and guns not so widely held (and sometimes used) as many people anticipate. While Americans may never say a total “farewell to arms,” there’s hope that one day, instead of lovingly embracing them, they’ll learn the wisdom of keeping guns properly and reasonably out of reach, or at least at arms-length.
Paul Binotto is a freelance writer living in Pittsburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.