History is not linear. And it does not yield simple lessons. I went to see “Oppenheimer” and I have been thinking about it since.
The acting and the cinematography are superb. But the film is also an essay on pride, science, and power.
Robert Oppenheimer was one of the two most important personalities to emerge from World War II. The other was Winston Churchill. Churchill saved his country and the world from Nazism. Oppenheimer created the weapon that definitively ended the war, or so we were long told. Churchill was almost immediately rejected by his countrymen after the war. Oppenheimer’s government turned on him during the red scare.
Human nature
Both outcomes underline one tragic aspect of humanity — we are not often, by nature, either grateful or loyal, though we highly value both traits.
Churchill recovered, returned to power and died a national hero, endlessly lionized since. He escaped the ultimate failure of most public men.
Read More
After the war, Oppenheimer was a wounded bird. His security clearance rescinded; his name tarnished. But in later years he was not without influence. He was lauded by the intelligentsia. And a few in Congress and the executive branch sought him out. He became a respected voice for reason in science and foreign policy.
He did suffer, but perhaps most from his own inner demons.
There were petty humiliations. But the greater humiliation was that the power men in Washington, both civilian and military, did not listen to him in 1946. One of the finest minds of his, or any, age was ignored once the bomb was delivered. Oppenheimer was a means to an end. His brilliance was a bauble to be traded for military victory. The great issues of war and peace were for the politicians. And the smaller minds used Oppenheimer.
The deeper tragedy of Robert Oppenheimer lies below even that: Oppenheimer believed that the monstrous power he had set loose upon the world — the bomb — could be managed. If only people as smart as Oppenheimer had control, Dr. Frankenstein could direct his own monster.
Oppenheimer saw the horrific human cost of the bomb, and it agonized him. He saw the hubris of the men of power. But he never grasped his own hubris or his own naivete.
And this brings us to our national hubris — tragedy on a grand scale: We have never fully faced the question of the bomb.
When I was a young man, the received wisdom was that Harry Truman had done the only thing he could have done: The bomb killed 200,000 Japanese, mostly non-combatants, but it ended the war quickly, and the Japanese would have fought on for years. Many more would have died in a protracted Pacific war, and many of those would be American soldiers.
But time and research suggest a more complicated truth, that the Japanese were beaten and could not have fought on. The bomb was not necessary to end the war.
Many historians believe this now and some substantial military men either came to believe it or believed it then. No less than Dwight David Eisenhower, to name one. Even Gen. George Marshall had private doubts.
Hitler, the reason for developing the bomb, was beaten and dead before the bomb was dropped. Japan was spent. The Russians were coming. But Oppenheimer and company were too far into the process. Momentum and will had as much to do with dropping the bomb as Japanese capacity.
Maybe.
History is often a layer cake of tragedy — level after level of hubris and folly and fog. This is the history of war, as well as the history of the arms race.
Tragic history
Film cannot study history. It can only open a window. This film, fine and serious as it is, never escapes the man. And Oppenheimer’s personal story is just the first layer of the cake.
The only nation that has used atomic weapons – a nation that presumes to be the moral leader of the world — needs to grapple anew not just with the psyche of Robert Oppenheimer but with the reality of the bomb — and 200,000 dead Japanese civilians.
Was Eisenhower right? Could we have bombed military targets alone? Done a demonstration first? Waited before dropping the second bomb?
Historian Evan Thomas, who has made this his subject, senator-scholar Daniel Patrick Moynihan, and Paul Fussell, a WWII soldier who won the Purple Heart, the Bronze Star, and became an important writer and critic, agreed with Truman.
There can be no final answer. But we owe ourselves fresh self-examination.
Truman comes off as something of a rube and a thug in the film. He was neither. But he was a person of certitude. He didn’t question himself. He didn’t agonize. He didn’t see gray. I wish Ike had been president in 1946. I wish that Oppenheimer’s doubts had come sooner.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Republicans, say no to Trump, and find someone else.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.