Like most people, my social media feeds and text threads are filled with Barbenheimer memes. They range from trite to clever to savagely ironic.
The most striking juxtaposes Barbie and Oppenheimer. Pretty in pink beside grey noir. Her caption reads: “My product first launched in Japan.” His is chillingly blank. The implied parallel is the “launch” of atomic weapons at Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Both movie and meme have renewed controversy over the bomb. Some regard its use as murderous war crimes. Many believe this was a regrettable necessity that shortened the war and mercifully saved lives. Both are correct.
As a matter of fact, the attacks forced Japan’s surrender and preempted invasion. Depending on which estimates you consult, this saved between a few hundred thousand to several million lives. Both civilians and soldiers. Japanese and Americans alike.
As a matter of principle, these attacks were murder. As a matter of law, they were war crimes. They willfully and knowingly targeted civilians and that is forbidden.
Strange as this may sound, it’s true. Hard as this might be to accept, it’s right.
Read More
A distinction
These judgments turn on the distinction between what philosophers call “absolutism” and “consequentialism.” Each expresses an unimpeachable moral intuition about our actions and obligations.
The absolutist intuition is that no matter how bad the negative consequences might be, no matter how great the positive outcomes could be, some actions remain forbidden. In Christian theology, this intuition is rooted in the “Pauline principle” that we must not “do evil so that good might result.” Virtuous ends cannot redeem vicious means.
The consequentialist intuition is that consequences, especially those that alleviate or eliminate suffering, trump conscience. In Christian theology, this intuition is grounded in the “golden rule” that we should “do unto others as we would have them do unto us.” Jewish Talmud puts it this way: “That which is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbor.” Either way, we must value the welfare of others more than our own moral purity.
These divergent intuitions arise from a shared assumption. The sanctity of human life and dignity of human persons are sacrosanct. Their safety and welfare cannot be violated without justification. Above all, they cannot be murdered. The justification that makes “killing” not “murder” is self-defense.
That Japan attacked Pearl Harbor and invaded across the Pacific justified war. Japanese “materially involved” in the conflict forfeited these protections. Soldiers, political leaders, and ordinary workers producing war matériel (arms, munitions, petroleum) became legitimate targets. Nonetheless, even soldiers revert to protected noncombatant status when incapacitated (wounded in hospitals, parachuting from disabled aircraft). Although workers may be targeted while in factories, they cannot be targeted in their homes.
Despite this shared assumption, these two moral intuitions collide at Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
The relevant absolutism is the theological, philosophical, moral, and legal traditions of just war. In the West, the tradition originated with Augustine in the fourth century and was formalized in the 1929 Geneva Convention.
The most consistent and stringent provision of just war is the principle of noncombatant immunity. Civilians are off limits to military operations. Soldiers must avoid harming civilians while targeting the enemy. Michael Walzer, the leading contemporary just war thinker, cautions, “You can neither aim at civilians, nor can you aim through them.”
Targeting military stations and industrial installations in Hiroshima and Nagasaki was legitimate. Obliterating a mile-wide swath of the city to do so was not. By official estimates of the Strategic Bombing Survey, the Hiroshima attack killed just under 7,000 soldiers and at least 70,000 civilians. The Enola Gay aimed through those many civilians to aim at those few soldiers.
Truman’s private assurance in his diary is self-deceptive pretext: “I told the Sec. of War, Mr. Stimson, to use it so that military objectives and soldiers and sailors are the target and not women and children.” His public reassurance to the nation is self-protective pretense: “The target was a purely military one.” Elizabeth Anscombe, the greatest modern just war thinker, made this plain in protest of Truman’s 1958 honorary Oxford degree: “For men to choose to kill the innocent as a means to their ends is always murder.”
The relevant consequentialism is the necessity of the bombing to prevent greater suffering. It points to the ferocity of Japanese defense at Okinawa and the expected savagery of their defense of the home islands. It says with Truman that “war itself is the real villain,” not the weapons.
Protests that war is lawless and amoral contradict themselves. To say “war” makes a moral judgment. To say “war” distinguishes this violence from the wanton violence of “terrorism” or “massacre.” We cannot say “war” without recognizing the moral and legal constraints that define this distinction.
The intuitions converge
Suppose Germany firebombed Detroit. Imagine Japan atomic bombed Houston. There are no circumstances in which Americans would have accepted their pleas that they had to do it, let alone that it was merciful to do it. Nor should they.
Here absolutist and consequentialist intuitions converge. We cannot kill and we should not do to others what is evil in itself or hateful to us. If atomic bombing of our civilians is not hateful to us, then nothing is.
Derek Woodard-Lehman is lecturer in theology and ethics at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary. His previous article was “The late queen — angelic national mother or demonic imperial master?”.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.