Vivek Ramaswamy is an interesting man. He is a 37-year-old self-made billionaire. He is Hindu. He seems to have been culturally conservative since childhood. He rose to prominence as an “anti-woke” activist. And he is emblematic of much that is wrong with our politics.

Mr. Ramaswamy has never held public office. And he is running for president.

He is a person who might make a decent candidate for Congress. Or mayor of Columbus, Ohio.

So what makes this young man think he could handle the presidency or is, in any way, qualified for the hardest political job in the world? What makes him think that being an anti-woke guru has prepared him for the White House? Would a 37 year old who, say, taught history and civics in a Columbus high school be taken seriously if he applied to be CEO of a tech or high finance company?

Advertise with us

But Mr. Ramaswamy has an ardent niche following that may grow. Indeed, he could conceivably become the Donald Trump of 2024; the Jimmy Carter of 2024.

Mr. Carter, and God bless that fine man, was the first to do it in our time. He was the first to conquer a presidential nomination by being new, unknown, unexpected, and undefiled by the highest level of our politics and its compromises. He was a one-term, ex-governor of Georgia. He had an original voice. And he was unemployed, so he could camp out in Iowa and sneak up on the establishment.

The “outsider” myth was born. Better a blank slate than someone from “the swamp.”

But, you know what? If you want to drain a swamp, you need to know something about swamps. If you want to run anything — a hospital, a zoo, a restaurant – your chances of succeeding are much improved if you have knowledge and experience. Mr. Carter would have been a more successful president if he had served in Congress or the Cabinet.

Donald Trump might have been just as divisive a person, and he might have gone just as nuts after losing the presidency, if he had first served as mayor of New York City. But at least he could have acquired some sense of how government works and how responsible politicians behave in office. Instead, he dragged many professional politicians down to his level, which was the level of shock jocks and social media.

Advertise with us

This brings me to a second dangerous myth — the myth of the message. “Make America Great Again,” is not a plan for governing. Nor is “Change.” Nor, “Yes We Can.”

Barack Obama spoke like a prophet and a poet. He had trouble governing, because government is prose; it is nitty gritty; it is scut work.

Government, especially at the federal level, is complex. Trade policy, Russia, NATO, China, nuclear arms, immigration, employment and unemployment — all these matters are incredibly complicated. If I’m going to try to get around the Swamp, give me the Swamp Thing.

Politics and government are the only professions in which we often see inexperience and ignorance as plusses.

If you need a neurologist, an ophthalmologist, an oncologist, you do not, from the gurney, call for the outsider. You do not say: Bring me someone with no experience in medicine, but with many opinions.

Advertise with us

Trump was the ultimate outsider and the ultimate disaster. And you want to know a big reason why?

He never learned.

There were good people willing to help him. But the thing about outsiders is that you can’t tell them anything. They think: If the pros really knew more, they would be in my chair.

That’s what Jimmy Carter was in 1976. His slogan was, “Why not the Best?” But his message was really: “Why not something new?”

That was Trump in 2016. But Trump’s message in 2024 is, “Let’s burn it all down.” Would you hire someone to run your family business, your church, or local elementary school with that message?

Advertise with us

Jimmy Carter was not the best in 1976. Jerry Ford was. He had been in Congress, had been vice president, and assumed the presidency in crisis. He had an able Cabinet. And he knew the swamp that overwhelmed Mr. Carter.

The best Republican in 2024 is not the newest face, or the one who makes you laugh the most, or is furthest to the right. It is the one with the most experience. Mike Pence has been a congressman, a governor and a vice president. When tested, he did not wilt or fade. You could not get odds on his nomination.

You don’t call for the outsider in the ER. Presidents should not be blank slates. Or innocent doves. They need the wisdom of the serpent.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “The mental martial arts of writing and laughter.”