There’s an ugly meme going around on the right mocking Senator John Fetterman in the worst way. Not because of his politics (fair game), but something much more vile. A Fox commentator posted an image titled “Three Vegetables” on top of pictures of Joe Biden, Dianne Feinstein … and John Fetterman.

On Twitter someone posted that Fetterman was a vegetable. I replied that he was stupid and cruel. Coming back at me, one user posted, “he is a vegetable tho.” Another: “He’s closer to mineral.” Still more: “he's unfit for his job, weekend at bernie's … Fetterman will always be a charity case who had no business being elected.”

Soon it became a chorus: “If a man can be Woman a veggie can be a politician … Was it a cabbage? Mushroom … He is 6 short of half a dozen”. One just posted three “tears of joy” emojis.

There is precedence for this. At the turn of the century municipalities passed “ugly laws,” making it illegal for persons with “unsightly or disfiguring” disabilities to appear in public. The first of these ordinances was in 1867 in San Francisco; this idea seems to have been welcomed from the 1800s in western and particularly midwestern cities.

Advertise with us

Chicago’s Municipal Code included a section that stipulated: “No person who is diseased, maimed, mutilated or in any way deformed so as to be an unsightly, disgusting or improper is to be allowed in or on the public ways or other public places in this city, or shall therein or thereon expose himself to public view, under penalty of not less than one dollar nor more than fifty dollars for each offense.” Note how this law explicitly included the word “disgusting.” It was not repealed till 1974. An 1877 New York case held that simply displaying one's disability in public (without even speaking) constituted begging and thus a violation of that state's law.

These laws stemmed from distaste with public pauperism, carried over to all those with deformities. In San Francisco a charity organization declared, “Pauperism is a disease upon the community, a sore upon the body politic, and being a disease, it must be, as far as possible, removed, and the curative purpose must be behind all our thought and effort for the pauper class." A recent commentator noted, “The ugly laws did not restrict performances of people with disabilities for the purpose of entertainment or eliciting disgust, but rather restricted people with disabilities from mingling with the general public.”

In the post-bellum period among the most common victims were veterans, former soldiers who had lost limbs or were disfigured during the Civil War. The first recorded arrest pertaining to ugly laws was Martin Oates in San Francisco in July 1867. Oates was a former Union soldier.

These laws have been used for various purposes.. The last recorded arrest stemming from the Ugly Laws was in 1974, under an Omaha ordinance. The man arrested was homeless, and the officer claimed he had visible scars and marks on his body.

The former president has always preferred to pick on the vulnerable. He opened the door to mocking persons with disabilities when he made fun of a reporter with arthrogryposis, a congenital condition affecting the joints. Not since vile opponent’s mocked FDR’S paralysis nearly a century ago has politics sunk this low.

Advertise with us

Trump opened the Pandora’s Box and through it ride the worst elements of society. While Tucker Carlson interviewed Dr. Mehnet Oz during the last election, a chyron underneath read, "You're not allowed to point out that Fetterman is a giant walking vegetable."

Donald Trump, Jr., said at CPAC, the big annual meeting of America’s conservatives, “It’s sort of weird that Pennsylvania managed to elect a vegetable. … I’d love for John Fetterman to have like, good gainful employment. Maybe he could be like a bag guy at a like a grocery store.” Even the National Review headlined, “Shame on Trump Jr. for Calling Fetterman a ‘Vegetable.’”

I use a motorized wheelchair. I expect — and have received — critiques of my written work, some quite severe. But please leave my paralyzed body alone.

Robert A. Slayton is professor emeritus in the department of history of Chapman University. He’s the author of “Empire Statesman,” a biography of Alfred E. Smith, “New Homeless and Old” and other books. He can be reached at slayton@chapman.edu.