The poet May Sarton wrote: “One must think like a hero to behave like a merely decent human being.” Let’s think like heroes for a minute.
Decency is the opposite of indecency, and thus, for many, modesty in manners and appearance. But decency is also moral modesty: I think what I think and I want what I want — but I am aware that there are other people in the home, office, world and I am willing to consider what they think and want.
Decency does not aim for enlightenment, goodness or even approximate justice, but something less ambitious — a kind of common ground of manners and consideration. Enlightenment, goodness and justice are high bars, as are charity, love and empathy. But we can start with decency. Decency is doable.
I associate decency, somehow, with Eastern Europeans. They saw so many pretty illusions in the last century. And they were burned. Thus, a writer and statesman like Vaclav Havel tended to speak less of absolutes like freedom and peace and more in terms of the tools of reason and a working sense of decency. No great answer to history for him, but an affirmation of the minimal requirements of social life for people who consider themselves human beings.
A sketch of a decency manifesto, a beginning:
- Don’t start wars.
- Respect borders, cultures and traditions.
- Don’t cancel people.
- Defend free speech and thought.
- Protect children.
- Don’t fan the flames of division.
Those are just decent things to do.
I also associate decency with a kind of American politician who is not currently much in evidence — the Hubert Humphrey Democrat and the Nelson Rockefeller Republican. They were pragmatic humanists. Not really left or right.
Lowell P. Weicker, a long-time senator from Connecticut, who passed the other day, was one of them. He was a senator for 18 years and one of the last of the “liberal” Republicans. I covered his “comeback.” He won the governorship after losing his Senate seat to the Tartuffe-like Joe Lieberman. Weicker was restless, irascible, fickle and often pompous as hell. Not a great governor because of his short attention span. But a credible senator, because he generally stood for decency.
Like Rockefeller, Weicker declined to become a Democrat because he thought Democrats sentimental and unrealistic. But certain issues, like public health, government-funded medical research, Apartheid in South Africa and presidents who saw themselves as above the law — these were matters of decency that superseded party and ideology.
We used to call him “Blowell.” But, for all his huffing and puffing, Lowell Weicker was genuine and grounded. He was Blowell the Good.
Ron DeSantis, on the other hand, is the unpragmatic, anti-humanist — willing to say anything to pander to Trump Nation. He wants to abolish the IRS but he cannot bring himself to condemn the violence and hate that occurred in Washington, D.C on January 6, 2021. It’s indecent.
The Supreme Court of the United States has now overturned previous high court law on abortion (formerly legal after the first trimester) and affirmative action. It has overruled the executive on student loan forgiveness.
Does anyone believe these were strictly Constitutional decisions, based on narrow legal reasoning? No, these were policy pronouncements by cultural warriors – not only injudicious but reckless. Not “originalist” and not “conservative,” but immodest. Indecent.
A true conservative justice is someone like the late Lewis F. Powell, Jr., who was a constitutionalist and a limited government man. And a friend of Weicker. He swore him in as governor. Or Justice Stephen Breyer, who always considered the consequences of Court opinions.
Even Chief Justice Earl Warren, whom the right attacked for decades as an uber activist who made up his own law, was modest in comparison with the current reactionary activists on the Court. Warren respected precedent, social stability and the other branches of government.
The truly conservative approach would be: Let us abjure the great concepts and slogans and simply try to be decent to each other: Listen. Consider each person as an individual, not part of a trend or tribe. Be kind. And if you can’t be kind, be polite. Sometimes I think Pope Francis is saying this when he warns against adopting ideologies, as he does consistently.
Mere decency has no party. But it ought to trump political party. Take gun violence and the concept of limiting gun rights. Ideology wraps gun rights in absolutist clothing. Decency lays reality bare.
Poet Matthew Olzmann writes: Can we agree Kevlar / backpacks shouldn’t be needed / for children walking to school?
And he quotes Czeslaw Milosz: You whom I could not save, / Listen to me.
Decency means listening. Reconsidering.
But the low bar is now high. The incivility of our public life, which first invaded culture, has now invaded our private lives — friendship and colleagueship. There is nothing “mere” about decency.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (burriscolumn@gmail.com). His previous article was “If only Donald Trump were as wise as Cary Grant.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.