The American Republic was forged on Pennsylvania soil, first with the Continental Congress that birthed the union, then with the Constitutional Convention 9 years later that molded it. The Constitution, with its Bill of Rights, underpins society today. But we can’t continue to achieve the Constitution’s “more perfect union” when segments of the population are relegated to second-tier status. It’s now up to the state Senate to include another group of our fellow citizens whose rights have not been legally protected.
In 2020, conservative Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote the majority opinion in the Supreme Court’s landmark Bostock v. Clayton County decision, which held that an employer cannot discriminate against an individual because of their sexual orientation. While this was a historic victory for civil rights, the decision does not prevent others (besides employers) from denying the LGBT community housing, education, or access to public accommodations simply because of who they are.
Studies indicate that more than 1 in 3 LGBT adults today face some form of discrimination in their daily lives. Some Pennsylvania towns, cities and counties – by last count nearly 100 of them – have passed ordinances outlawing discrimination. More than 2,000 other local municipalities have not. Their LGBT citizens could still face legal discrimination in the public sphere.
State lawmakers have sought to right this wrong with the Fairness Act, legislation that would amend the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act (PHRA) to prohibit discrimination in housing, employment, and public accommodations on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. PHRA protections already exist on the basis race, color, religion, ancestry, age, sex, national origin and disability. It also includes explicit language “for protection of religious exercise.” Three Allegheny County representatives — Jessica Benham, Dan Frankel and La’Tasha D. Mayes — were among the prime sponsors.
In a historic 102-98 vote last month, the Pennsylvania House of Representatives passed the Fairness Act. The responsibility now rests with the Senate to strengthen civil rights and rescind a clear deterrent for workers and businesses who could help grow our state’s economy.
In a recent survey by Centerline Action, 71% of Pennsylvania voters support passage of the Fairness Act, and less than one-in-five (18%) oppose it. The bill also enjoys support from a 51 of Republicans, 73% among Independents and 90% of Democrats. Even 55% of Pennsylvanians who voted for President Trump in 2020 support passage.
Read More
Centerline also found that when respondents were asked to think about the Fairness Act and its implications, 70% of voters statewide agreed that “everyone has a right to earn a living — including gay and transgender Americans – and workers should be judged on performance, nothing more, nothing less.” Two-thirds of Republican primary voters and Independents share this sentiment.
Over the next three years, all Americans will take time to pause and reflect upon what it means to live in a place where freedom can be cherished by all. Sustaining the American Dream, along with ingenuity and societal progress is predicated on fairness, opportunity, and simply treating others as we would want to be treated.
Pennsylvania state representatives have passed the Fairness Act. Senators have an opportunity to set a marker by which the state and nation measures its faithfulness to the values of our Constitution. Passing this necessary nondiscrimination bill into law will punctuate Pennsylvania’s role in fortifying a more perfect union.
Alicia Downs is a principal at TargetPoint, a Republican polling and research firm. James Dozier is the founder & board president of Centerline Action.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.